Check a vehicle VIN check Latest recalls Latest complaints Common problems Rankings Compare vehicles Recall roundups All makes Guides Share your experience
Theme

Suspension

BMW 323I Suspension problems by year

18 complaints filed with NHTSA about the BMW 323I's suspension. Broken springs, struts, control arms, ball joints, noises and alignment that won't hold.

Suspension complaints by model year

YearSuspension complaintsCrashesInjuriesRecalls
200010000
19998000

Latest 323I suspension complaints

2000 BMW 323ISuspension

The contact owns a 2000 BMW 323I. The contact stated that while driving at highway speeds, an abnormal rattling noise would emit from the rear end of the vehicle without warning. Upon inspection, the contact discovered part of the rear driver's side subframe had detached from the undercarriage of the vehicle. The contact called the dealer about the failure and they offered no assistance. The manufacturer had yet to be notified of the failure. The vehicle had yet to be repaired. The failure mileage was 205,721

Filed Incident SuspensionNHTSA 11446358
2000 BMW 323ISuspensionBody, doors & structure

Rear subframe body has separated from subframe mounting support. The chassis is no longer properly attached to the frame. The tied down bolts have sheared off. This is a major safety defect.

Filed Incident Suspension · Structure · Unknown or otherNHTSA 10957896
1999 BMW 323ISuspension

Tl* the contact owns a 1999 bmw 323i. While inspecting the undercarriage of the vehicle, it was noticed that there was a fracture near the mounting of the rear suspension of the subframe. The vehicle was not diagnosed or repaired. The manufacturer was not made aware of the failure. The failure mileage was 180,600.

Filed Incident SuspensionNHTSA 10786159
2000 BMW 323ISuspensionBody, doors & structureDriver assistance

I was unaware of the previous defect notices about the frame / body having a weak spot and was driving at 40 mph when my rear shock and the part that holds the shock in place went through the metal frame ripping the metal away and allowing the shock to puncture through the frame just below the trunk area and the car was then inoperable. I was quoted a price for repair of 6500 and was informed of the 2005/2006 lawsuit where bmw was sued for this defect and repaired some cars for a year after the lawsuit ended but...

Read the full complaint

this was prior to my purchase of the vehicle and when I contacted bmw of no america headquarters, they asked me to take the car to the nearest bmw dealer and have them do a diagnosis which I immediately did and that cost was over $10k of which bmw offered to pay only 20%. I then took it to another bmw mechanic who repaired it for $3000 and bmw will not pay any part of the bill because it was not done at a dealership, I do not understand how bmw can get away with a defect like this and so many cars affected by it and not have to repair it at their cost? It is their defect. *Tr

Filed Incident Suspension · Structure · Electronic stability control (ESC)NHTSA 10633359
1999 BMW 323ISuspensionBody, doors & structure

After 6 months of squeaking & rattling sounds coming from the rear of my vehicle, I was driving on ca route 10 when I noticed the sounds were becoming more prevalent, as the car's handling began to feel loose. I reduced speed for the remainder of the trip, fearing loss of control of the vehicle, and upon arriving home had my vehicle inspected by beverly hills bmw, where they told me that my vehicle's subframe was damaged to the extent that the car was "not road worthy" ([[redacted]]) and I was advised to have the...

Read the full complaint

vehicle towed out of the shop. I contacted bmw customer service agent [[redacted]], who informed me that bmw had a program (that I believe is part of a settlement agreement of a class action lawsuit), in which they recognized there was a problem with some of the early e46 bmw models' sub-frames and offered to have them inspected & in some cases would pay for the cost of the repair. Bmw chose to deny me repair, citing that they had mailed me a letter about the program previously (that I had never received) & that the program had now ended. After having my vehicle repaired by an independent party, I contacted[[redacted]]to see if bmw would reimburse me for some of my costs of repair and car rental, seeing as how they were a fraction of the quote from bmw. She told me to forward my invoices ($2207.70 In total) to her email, which I did. Despite 3 follow-up emails, 3 voice mails, and one certified letter, I have received no further communication from bmw. The mechanical / structural integrity of a vehicle's frame, or sub-frame, should never be compromised by regular use. Having a defective sub-frame in a car manufactured in the last 80 years is wholly unacceptable and constitutes a need for investigation concerning a potential recall, rather than some manufacturer-controlled program with time limits that affect the safety of its customers. Information redacted pursuant to the freedom of information act (foia), 5 u.S.C. 552(B)(6). *Tr

Filed Incident Suspension · StructureNHTSA 10488722
2000 BMW 323ISteeringSuspensionBrakesElectrical systemAcceleration & cruise control

After having the control arm bushings replaced and a 4 wheel alignment completed at a bmw service dealership in tyler, tx, apparently the steering angle sensor (located at the bottom of the steering column) failed which caused the dynamic stability control (dsc), brake and abs lights to illuminate. When the incident occurred, I was driving 70 mph on a dry highway using the cruise control. When this sensor failed, all three lights illuminated and the cruise control ceased to work. According to the bmw service...

Read the full complaint

department, there is no requirement to re-calibrate the steering angle sensor after an alignment is completed. Additionally, per the service manager at the bmw service department, they are replacing steering angle sensors in a variety of bmw automobiles at "3 to 4 per week". Estimated cost to repair is between $500 - $1000. *Tr

Filed Incident Steering · Suspension · Service brakes, hydraulic · Electrical system · Vehicle speed controlNHTSA 10444910
1999 BMW 323ISuspensionBody, doors & structure

The subframe has ripped away from the floorpan. Through investigation this has been determined to be a very common failure on e46 bmw 3 series. This should be a mandatory recall by bmw to fix this issue. The subframe should last the life of any car. *Tr

Filed Incident Suspension · StructureNHTSA 10439853
1999 BMW 323ISuspension

Rear sub frame tear greater then 20 mm when inspected by the bmw dealer

Filed Incident SuspensionNHTSA 10409648
2000 BMW 323ISuspensionBody, doors & structure

Heard loud noises coming from rear end of vehicle. Upon inspection by repair facility it was determined that the rear drivers side subframe mount had pulled away from the body, a large tear is present in the body panel on either side of the subframe mount. Repair facility indicated the risk is that the car may not respond as expected in an emergency or evasive action. Form would not allow me to complete vin, last character is a 2.

Filed Incident Suspension · StructureNHTSA 10406385
2000 BMW 323ISuspensionBody, doors & structure

My 2000 bmw 323i has sub frame fractures as defined in a class action lawsuit against bmw. In the settlement, bmw has agreed to inspect and repair all effected vehicles. The dealer told me my car was unrepairable and offered me a cash settlement well below avg trade-in value. I want my car fixed. *Tr

Filed Incident Suspension · StructureNHTSA 10278652
2000 BMW 323ISuspensionBrakesFuel systemTransmission & drivetrain

A year ago, my gas gauge sensor went out. The car had less than 100,000 miles on it. Today, my 2000 bmw 323i has 111,000 miles on it and the vehicle will not drive in any gear without a grinding sound. I almost got killed by a car behind me because I could suddenly not accelerate at a stop light and I had to get out to push the vehicle to safety. Within the past few months the car would drive, but only when it was warm. Now it is completely inop. This car has been well maintained! It would cost me over $4000 to get...

Read the full complaint

a new transmission and I still over $6000 on the car. Despite thousands of complaints regarding the 2000 bmw 323i transmission failure, bmw refuses to do anything. I currently have no operable vehicle and I still have to maintain my auto loan payments and find alternate transportation to work. I have spent over $3500 in additional repairs to this vehicle on brakes, new catalytic converter sensors, trailing arm, ball bearings, etc. *Tr

Filed Incident Suspension · Service brakes, hydraulic · Fuel system, gasoline · Power trainNHTSA 10263920
2000 BMW 323ISuspension

On my 2000 bmw 323i with about 100k miles I noticed a creaking noise coming from the rear suspension. Upon inspection, the drivers side rear differential mount has separated at the point where the mount is welded to the uni-body. This situation is very dangerous and requires immediate attention. The suspension should never separate from the body because of forces from the trans/diff. It is clear that this is a design flaw. I personally have a list of over 150 names with documented subframe cracking/failure of...

Read the full complaint

the e46 body years 1999-2000. The overwhelming majority of these have subframe damage at the same rear drivers side diff mount, in other words, out of four possible failure points, the rear drivers side is nearly always the failure point !! I urge the nhtsa to address this issue immediately somebody gets hurt or dies! *Jb

Filed Incident SuspensionNHTSA 10179185
2000 BMW 323ISuspension

While driving 30 mph consumer heard a loud squeaking noise coming from the front. Vehicle jerked and vibrated uncontrollably. It was taken to the dealer for inspection. *Ak

Filed Incident SuspensionNHTSA 10101405
1999 BMW 323ISuspension

While driving consumer noticed a thumping sound. Consumer had the vehicle serviced by a technician, who noticed that rear suspension cross member mount tore away from the floorboard. *Ak

Filed SuspensionNHTSA 10073472

Source: U.S. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) complaints and recalls, checked daily. Complaints are owners' own reports and are not verified. How we use the data

Owners helping owners

Know before you drive.

Every experience you share - good or bad - shows on that vehicle's page and helps the next owner and buyer. Two minutes, anonymous.

Share your experience