Check a vehicle VIN check Latest recalls Latest complaints Common problems Rankings Compare vehicles Recall roundups All makes Guides Share your experience
Theme

Engine & cooling

BMW M3 Convertible Engine problems by year

31 complaints filed with NHTSA about the BMW M3 Convertible's engine & cooling. Stalling, loss of power, oil consumption, overheating, head gaskets, timing chains and engine failure.

Engine complaints by model year

YearEngine complaintsCrashesInjuriesRecalls
20043000
200311000
200217000

Latest M3 Convertible engine complaints

2003 BMW M3 ConvertibleElectrical systemEngine & cooling

Tl* the contact owns a 2003 bmw m3. The contact stated that the electrical system shorted out and all the electrical devices failed to work. The vehicle decelerated without warning and the engine went into limp mode and lost power. All the warning indicators illuminated on the instrument panel. The vehicle was towed to an independent mechanic who diagnosed that a new battery was needed and a part on the fuse box needed to be replaced. The manufacturer and dealer were not made aware of the failure. The failure mileage was 98,000. The vin was unknown.

Filed Incident Electrical system · EngineNHTSA 11246068
2003 BMW M3 ConvertibleSuspensionEngine & cooling

Originar request car gone for repair: main issue; leak of anti-free, pump issue. Hose replacement. 2012 - Package results no included in our original requests. Suspension problem: tech found both rear coil springs broken. Note by car's owner: we when ahead and replaced both, although around 90% of my drive is in highways and my frequent passenger is only a 3 year old boy. Repair cost: us$400.00 --------------------------------------- 2015- Car brought over the dealership for "computer programming" as...

Read the full complaint

service was not available anywhere. Recommended services by the dealership: - "replace rear coil springs with lower pads. (Both rear coil springs are broken) note: - although, we 'd like to make this repair we did not agreed to do so. - The tag price scaled to us766.28 Without tax and we've been in a tight budget. - You may try searching online for "bmw rear coil springs complain, issue or problems." There are literally hundreds of complains on bmw's rear spring fail but still not recall, ( although by bmw own admission this should be consider a serious safety issue. *Tr

Filed Incident Suspension · Engine and engine coolingNHTSA 10676843
2003 BMW M3 ConvertibleEngine & cooling

P133 code has come up after driving 100 miles. I took the car to a local mechanic in which he replaced all oxygen sensors. A few weeks later the code came back up. I took the car back to the mechanic in which he said it has to do with a faulty ecm. This has caused me to fail smog test unless I erase the code. The ecm has already been reflashed by bmw back in 2012. *Tr

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 10604982
2002 BMW M3 ConvertibleTransmission & drivetrainElectrical systemEngine & cooling

I am filing this complaint on behalf of myself and the countless others experiencing this potentially fatal defect in bmw's smg pump unit. I was driving on the freeway for about 5 minutes when I noticed my car immediately shifted into neutral without me making that decision. I was in the middle of changing lanes when this happened. The smg warning light came on. I put my hazards on. The car abruptly slowed as it chose to shift back to 4th gear as I was going 65mph. I tried shifting back up to gear safely get to the...

Read the full complaint

shoulder but with no luck as the vehicle went back into neutral. The cars behind me came very rapidly and two almost hit me as a result of this pump failure. By this time I was traveling around 40mph in a 65+ traffic zone. I finally rolled my car down the shoulder to safety. I replaced the smg relay with a spare new one I always carried in the car. I waited 10 minutes for the vehicle to cool off as I knew this was the infamous smg pump issue. The car started back up with no light and drove me almost the entire route back home. Just about a mile from my home, same thing happened. This time leaving me completely stuck in a busy intersection. Luckily, the people behind me were kind enough to help push my car out of the way. I called a friend and we pushed the car all the way back to my garage. Now this is just the first time it has happened. It happens in less than 3 minutes of driving the car just when I try to move it never breaking 15mph. Bmwna ignores our complaints as their dealerships make money hand over fist with this $4000 repair. My complaint is not with the repair amount. Us m3 owners are aware of the maintenance and repair costs for our highly specialized vehicles. However, this pump malfunction is a very real danger to all drivers. We've seen this happen to vehicles with anywhere from 15k to 120k miles on them. Bmw needs to issue a recall. *Tr

Filed Incident Power train · Electrical system · EngineNHTSA 10598930
2002 BMW M3 ConvertibleTransmission & drivetrainElectrical systemEngine & coolingFuel system

This is not as much a complaint as a request for help. Since march of 2013 I have replaced 5 throttle bodies and 3 gas pedal sensors, all oem parts. The problem that happened again today: driving at normal highway speed [55/60] the eml, traction control and brake warning lights all went on. Pulled over and turned off. Restarted, now "service engine, eml, traction control and brake lights" were on. Turned off, restarted, same lighting situation, very rough idle and car would not drive, as it was struggling for fuel....

Read the full complaint

Unplugged the "mass air flow sensor": car started, displayed no warning lights, drove fine about 8 miles to repair shop. Code read shows, "throttle position sensor", replaced..Same problem within minutes of driving. A little internet research on e46 finds this an all to common problem with no solution. Thanks in advance. *Tr

Filed Incident Power train · Electrical system · Engine · Fuel / propulsion systemNHTSA 10586396
2004 BMW M3 ConvertibleEngine & cooling

One of the vanos exhaust hub tab broke and damaged the oil pump disc. I had to replace the vanos exhaust hub and oil pump disc. *Js

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 10579266
2003 BMW M3 ConvertibleEngine & cooling

The bmw e46 3-series (1999-2006) suffers from a design flaw in the cooling system. Plastic parts in the cooling system fail as soon as 4 years and 80,000 miles from manufacture date, often failing catastrophically and causing the engine to overheat. Continued driving of the car in this situation leads to complete engine failure and loss of power (including power steering and power brakes), potentially causing an accident if it happens at highway speeds. Typical failed parts include the coolant expansion tank,...

Read the full complaint

radiator end tanks, and water pump impellers or bearings. (Bmw came up with an improved water pump design around 2004 that is more reliable.) Cars with automatic transmissions also suffer failures of the mechanical fan clutch and the transmission cooling thermostat. Failure of the fan clutch (found only on automatic transmission cars) can cause the fan blades to break off and damage the radiator, serpentine belt, and water pump, as well as the car's hood. At higher mileages (>150,000 miles) the plastic coolant pipes often fail, causing overheating and requiring major work to replace. On my car the coolant expansion tank and radiator both failed and were replaced. The thermostat also stuck open resulting in lower gas mileage until it was replaced. Now one of my plastic coolant pipes is leaking. Bmw should be required to repair failed plastic cooling system parts on the e46 3-series with higher-quality parts designed to last at least 10 years and 100,000 miles from manufacture date. *Tr

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 10577923
2004 BMW M3 ConvertibleTransmission & drivetrainEngine & coolingFuel system

Vehicle drops out of gear randomly. As I was taking a left turn, the vehicle dropped into 0 gear and on coming traffic almost ran into me head on. I had no way of moving the car due to transmission being shifted into neutral. This is due to a defective temperature sensor on the smg pump. Bmw ignores the issue.

Filed Incident Power train · Engine · Fuel / propulsion systemNHTSA 10542312
2003 BMW M3 ConvertibleTransmission & drivetrainAcceleration & cruise controlEngine & cooling

While driving on a relatively hot day (92 degrees f), my vehicle's smg (sequential manual gearbox) malfunction indicator light turned on and I began having problems with the vehicle randomly dropping out of gear into neutral or "0" for 6-15 seconds at a time. When out of gear, there was a complete loss of power. On one instance of dropping out of gear, I was turning right at around 10-15 mph when I found I could not accelerate and an oncoming vehicle almost ran into me. Since the first occurrence of this, this type...

Read the full complaint

of "stalling" has happened much more frequently when the ambient temperature reaches above 90 degrees, and now I cannot drive longer than 30 minutes without the smg mil turning on and gears start dropping. I'm concerned that this may happen at higher speeds and leave me stranded on a highway or even in stop-and-go traffic, where it seems to occur very frequently. I've researched many forums for this and have found this to be a common issue with other m3 smg owners. There is some indication from other owners that the issue might be linked to a hydraulic temperature sensor located on the main smg hydraulic pump but I have not found any information from bmw detailing a repair for this type of issue. The only option seems to be a full replacement of the hydraulic pump, which has already been done on my vehicle once before for a similar issue. This type of replacement costs almost $4000 as quoted by the dealer. I think bmw should get serious about this issue and conduct an investigation on potential campaign remedies. *Tr

Filed Incident Power train · Vehicle speed control · EngineNHTSA 10471564
2002 BMW M3 ConvertibleEngine & cooling

The exhaust cam hub tabs break off on the 2000-2008 bmw m3 models. If caught when only one tab breaks it can be replaced. If both tabs break completely off the engine will seize. There are hundreds of people with the same issue. Bmw na will not address this issue. *Js

Filed Incident Engine and engine coolingNHTSA 10452496
2004 BMW M3 ConvertibleEngine & cooling

Before I start explaining, I should mention that the car has been meticulously maintained with majority of the parts being genuine bmw. The chassis has 110,[redacted] miles at the moment, and the engine has 78,[redacted] miles. The engine had a failure in 2006 due to a rod bearing failure (recalled from bmw), and a remanufactured engine has been installed by bmw technicians at a bmw dealership service center in virginia. Recently my 2004 bmw m3 had a failure inside the engine that could have been very dangerous....

Read the full complaint

On halloween night 2011, as I was leaving the gas station, I hear a very faint rattling noise up in the engine bay. I was contemplating rather I should take the car to the local dealership, or fix it myself. But prior to this, I've read many unsatisfying experiences people had at their local bmw dealerships. I worried that since this was a major problem that could be life threatening, I decided to do the work myself. I removed the valve cover, and noticed the exhaust side hub on of the bmw double vanos has failed. A mechanism designed to improve torque and fuel consumption. The hub had one of the 2 tabs completely broken off. Luckily the broken tab was still stuck inside the oil pump. If instead the broken piece came out of its location, and moved around in a engine this could cause a catastrophic failure. Ranging anywhere from approx $15,000 remanufactured engine replacement to possibly a high speed collision if the car was in motion during the failure. With a damaged engine, it is difficult to follow the minimum speed limit of 40 mph on the local freeway. The total replacement parts in my situation costs well over $3000 using bmw parts. Unfortunately, even with the current replacement parts from bmw, the problem would not be fixed since the currently new parts have just as much chance of failing as the old. *Js

Filed Incident Engine and engine coolingNHTSA 10452254
2003 BMW M3 ConvertibleEngine & cooling

The cooling fan broke loose spontaneously and flew through the air cutting through the hood of the car and ripping through the entire engine compartment. Moments prior the hood had been open with people standing around looking at the hoses. Had the fan broke loose at this time, I would have seriously injured or killed people. *Tr

Filed Incident Engine and engine coolingNHTSA 10436090
2002 BMW M3 ConvertibleEngine & cooling

I have a bmw m3 which has an smg transmission. I was driving and all of a sudden my car loses power to change the gears and my car started to jerk while on the road nearly crashing into another car. It turns out that the smg pumps for bmw m3 have always a high failure design flaw. The cost to fix that is also unbearable which nears the $5,000 mark. There has been forums going around that this is indeed a design flaw for bmw. I almost nearly got into a car accident, but thankfully I was ok. Please look into this matter as I feel as well as everyone else in the bmw comunittee that it should be a recall. Thank you for your time. *Tr

Filed Incident Engine and engine coolingNHTSA 10430221
2002 BMW M3 ConvertibleEngine & cooling

I own a 2002 bmw m3. There are six camshaft bolts behind a plate cover. Bmw speced bolts that were too soft until 2004 when they changed bolt spec to a hardened steel with loctite. Prior to this the bolts had no loctite. The issue is starting to surface all over the web. The failure is that the bolts do not stay screwed in. They back out and stop against the plate cover. Eventually they shear off and if this happens it causes catastrophic failure to your engine. In my case I was going 15mph so the damage was only...

Read the full complaint

$10,000. The car hammered to a stop. Bmw is refusing to acknowledge the issue suggesting out of warranty. My concern is that I have 60k on the car when the issue occurred first. A p0011 camshaft timing fault comes up. A bmw service center cleared the fault and replaced some coils and sparkplugs ($663) and sent me on my way. Three days later the bolts sheared. The dealership said they "had never seen this before". They also said bmw had issued no bulletins to address the bolts. Every independent bmw facility I interviewed in portland was well aware of the issue and already doing engine rebuilds for their customers. I think this is gross negligence on bmw's part for not acknowledging the issue and dealing with it. I also think the dealer is guilty of clearing the fault without checking further. The bid on my work is $10,000 (two valve heads and a vanos system plus 50 hours of labor). This is an estimate until they pull the engine apart more. Online you can see on you tube my issue by watching this video. On all the forums there are threads to see the issue. You can see this by a google search of "bmw camshaft bolt shearing" http://www.Youtube.Com/watch?V=r6rdvbhscfg bottom line is if the bolts are not replaced eventually they will shear off and cause catastrophic engine damage. The faster the speed of the car the worse the damage. The problem is appearing it seems after 30k and for many including me between 60-90k. *Tr

Filed Incident Engine and engine coolingNHTSA 10344604

Source: U.S. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) complaints and recalls, checked daily. Complaints are owners' own reports and are not verified. How we use the data

Owners helping owners

Know before you drive.

Every experience you share - good or bad - shows on that vehicle's page and helps the next owner and buyer. Two minutes, anonymous.

Share your experience