Since purchasing my new homesteader stallion 3-horse trailer in september 2004, all five of the original carlisle 235/r16 tires have blown with the tread separating (photos have been taken). The result has been damage to our trailer with fenders being blown off and/or damaged, and the siding of our trailer damaged. The last two tires blew within two days of each other. The date listed below is the last incident. It nearly caused an accident each time the tire blew as we were usually on a freeway hauling horses. *Jb
2001-2005 · 3 model years
Homesteader Hercules Problems by year
Owners have filed 4 complaints about the Homesteader Hercules across 3 model years, and it has 0 recalls. The 2004 has the most complaints once its age is allowed for (2). The most reported problem area is the wheels & tires, followed by the equipment & accessories.
- Complaints
- 4
- Recalls
- 0
- Crashes
- 0
- Fires
- 0
- Injuries
- 0
- Deaths
- 0
Hercules complaints by model year
Highlighted: the year with the most complaints for its age. Older vehicles have had more time to collect complaints - the Safety Index grade allows for that.
Most common Hercules problems
Latest Hercules complaints
Have had two new trailers that came equipped with carlisle tires. One tire on each trailer had tread separation before they had 2,000 miles. The tires were properly inflated and not overloaded. The first one (single axle trailer) blew suddenly and damaged the fender on the trailer. On the second trailer (tandem axle tire size st175/80r13) the bulge on the tire was felt, pulled over and replaced it. The first time, had both tires replaced immediately with a different brand leaving only a carlyle as a spare. In the process of replacing the four new tires and the spare now. Can not trust any carlyle product. *Tr
Dt: the consumer stated that the 2001 homesteader hercules 6x10 hs enclosed cargo trailer blew a tire. When the tire shredded it tore the fender of the trailer. The tire had proper air pressure in it. The consumer contacted the manufacturer of the trailer, and they thought that all cargo trailers were made tof he same. The tire and the fender were replaced by the consumer. The manufacturer is homesteader of new tazwell, tennessee. The tire is a carlisle. The location is left wheel. The trailer is a single axle.*Ak
While driving at 70 mph right front tire exploded. The explosion ripped the fender off the vehicle that trailer was towing. Fender, in turn, flew off and backwards, damaging the rear of vehicle. *Ak
Questions about the Homesteader Hercules
Which Homesteader Hercules years have the most problems?
What are the most common Homesteader Hercules problems?
Across every model year, owners report problems with the wheels & tires (4), equipment & accessories (1) most often.
How many recalls does the Homesteader Hercules have?
NHTSA lists no recalls for any Homesteader Hercules model year on file.
Source: U.S. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) complaints and recalls, checked daily. Complaints are owners' own reports and are not verified. How we use the data