Check a vehicle VIN check Latest recalls Latest complaints Common problems Rankings Compare vehicles Recall roundups All makes Guides Share your experience
Theme

2009-2019 · 2 model years

Indian Chief Roadmaster Problems by year

Owners have filed 4 complaints about the Indian Chief Roadmaster across 2 model years, and it has 3 recalls. The 2009 has the most complaints once its age is allowed for (1). The most reported problem area is the electrical system, followed by the steering.

Most complaints for its age20091 complaint · 3 recallsSee the 2009
Complaints
4
Recalls
3
Crashes
1
Fires
0
Injuries
1
Deaths
0

Chief Roadmaster complaints by model year

Highlighted: the year with the most complaints for its age. Older vehicles have had more time to collect complaints - the Safety Index grade allows for that.

YearComplaintsRecallsCrashesFiresTop problemGrade
20193000Electrical system-
20091310Body, doors & structure-

Most common Chief Roadmaster problems

Indian Chief Roadmaster recalls 3

Latest Chief Roadmaster complaints

2019 Indian Chief RoadmasterElectrical system

I was almost killed when my gear indicator switch suddenly went from 6th gear to neutral, therefore disengaging the cruise control. This caused a sudden decrease in speed due to engine braking which almost resulted in me getting rear ended. I could hear tires chirping behind me but luckily, I was able to regain my speed. This issue happens without warning and I have previously tried to get this fixed 3 times. All they do for the "fix" is clean the switch. This only lasts for about 8k miles. This is the same...

Read the full complaint

switch that was previously recalled due to a potential startup in 2nd gear. It is still "oxidizing" as stated in the original recall. IMO, they have made the issue even worse where the issue now occurs at speed. It also causes the bike to indicate 2nd gear when you are indeed, in neutral. Indian knows about this and has come up with a fix for mid 2019 models and subsequent. The crankcase and gear shift part numbers were changed and the gear indicator switch is clearly different. But it is apparently, not retrofittable to 2014 through early 2019 bikes. This is gross misconduct, IMO, and Indian is knowingly putting riders at risk. I am including an Indian forum thread to show that I am not the only one with this problem, https://www.indianmotorcycles.net/threads/gear-indicator-issue.338723/ There are many more threads on this issue besides this one. Please investigate this matter. I don't think I should have to call Indian or let them call this a maintenance item I have to pay for every 8k miles. This amounts to twice a year for me. That is very excessive. It is also rewarding them for their defective part. The "maintenance" is not easy or cheap. Multiple parts have to come off the bike to even get to the switch. It also takes me two months to get an appointment at my dealer so it is not getting fixed promptly. Mine, and others, safety is at risk. Please help. Thanks - [[redacted]] INFORMATION Redacted PURSUANT TO THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT (FOIA), 5 U.S.C. 552(B)(6).

Filed Incident Electrical systemNHTSA 11522014
2019 Indian Chief RoadmasterTransmission & drivetrainElectrical system

The contact owns a 2019 Indian Chief Roadmaster Motorcycle. The contact stated that while riding 60 MPH with the cruise control activated, the cruise control erroneously deactivated causing the motorcycle to suddenly decelerate. During the failure another vehicle nearly crashed into the rear of the motorcycle. The cause of the failure was not yet determined. The contact stated that the failure started after the motorcycle was repaired under NHTSA Campaign Number: 19V776000 (Electrical System, Power Train). The manufacturer was notified of the failure. The failure mileage was 9,000.

Filed Incident Power train · Electrical systemNHTSA 11521350
2019 Indian Chief RoadmasterElectrical system

The gear position sensor will go from 6th gear to neutral causing you to either drop out of cruise control (if engaged) or a momentary loss of power, if the cruise is not engaged. This can create a dangerous condition due to a sudden decrease in speed, if anybody is behind you. This is a motorcycle so there is nothing between you and any other vehicle. This was already supposed to have been fixed based on a recall I believe initiated here. That was for people accidentally starting their motorcycles in gear. As...

Read the full complaint

alleged on the internet, all Indian did was switch resistance values so now the issue I am reporting here is occurring. People are living (I hope!) with this condition as they were either told by Indian they are out of warranty or they are out of warranty and don't think anything can be done. Since there is no word of Indian supplying a new, improved gear position sensor to those afflicted, I can only assume that Indian is still producing thousands of new bikes that will have this problem. Looking at the additional details below. This occurs every time I ride my bike. The speed it occurs at 50+ mph as that is when you would be in 6th gear. This started occurring at about 11k miles. Thank you - George

Filed Incident Electrical systemNHTSA 11419512
2009 Indian Chief RoadmasterSteeringBody, doors & structureCrash1 injury

Weld failure on the fork stops on a 2009 indian motorcycle. Caused the motorcycle to lose control on numerous occasions and resulted in a rider losing control and crashing the motorcycle. The weld on the fork down tube that prevents the handle bars from turning too far broke off and caused a rider to crash. Upon inspection of the weld after the crash it is clearly visible that the weld is not sufficient to hold the fork stop in place. Review of the call out sheets for the assembly of the bikes calls for a 1/4...

Read the full complaint

inch weld all the way around the fork stop lug. This lug has a 1/16th tack weld on 3 sides. It appears to be a tack weld that was put on to hold the lug in place prior to final weld. The problem encountered is that when the weld breaks it allows the bars to be turned too far resulting in an ability to oversteer the motorcycle. I had this over steer happen to me on 3 occasions and couldn't figure out what had happened. The owner of the bike was not so lucky. It caused him to crash in a low speed turn. I know of 1 other incident where a rider went down in a low speed turn while on a demo ride in the north east area of the united states. I can provide pictures of the lug and welds and I can provide call out sheets for the weld from an earlier version of the frame that was assembled in gilroy, california. Please feel free to contact me with any questions. This issue really concerns me as there is no way to tell when the lug might break. In the wrong circumstances the over steer can result in serious potential for bodily injury. I have contacted mr. Chris bernauer the general manager of indian motorcycle on numerous occasions about this incident and he refuses to discuss it with me. I can also tell you indian motorcycle company bought the motorcycle back from the owner mr. John white and now has it in their kings mountain facility. I suspect part of the buy back agreement was an nda. I am not bound by any nda and rode the machine 8700 mile. *Tr

Filed Incident Steering · StructureNHTSA 10284497

Questions about the Indian Chief Roadmaster

Which Indian Chief Roadmaster years have the most problems?

By the number of complaints owners filed with NHTSA: 2019 (3), 2009 (1). Allowing for how long each has been on the road, the 2009 stands out most. Complaint counts also rise with sales, so compare years of the same model rather than different models.

What are the most common Indian Chief Roadmaster problems?

Across every model year, owners report problems with the electrical system (3), steering (1), transmission & drivetrain (1) most often.

How many recalls does the Indian Chief Roadmaster have?

NHTSA lists 3 recalls across all Indian Chief Roadmaster model years. Each year's page lists the recalls for that year; check your own vehicle by VIN at nhtsa.gov/recalls to see whether the repair has been done.

Source: U.S. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) complaints and recalls, checked daily. Complaints are owners' own reports and are not verified. How we use the data

Owners helping owners

Know before you drive.

Every experience you share - good or bad - shows on that vehicle's page and helps the next owner and buyer. Two minutes, anonymous.

Share your experience