Brake design issue.
Brakes
Kia Carnival Brake problems by year
10 complaints filed with NHTSA about the Kia Carnival's brakes. Spongy or hard pedal, ABS faults, brake failure, noises, parking brake and brake fluid leaks.
Brake complaints by model year
Latest Carnival brake complaints
What component or system failed or malfunctioned, and is it available for inspection upon request? Unable to determine casue, Yes it's available at body shop How was your safety or the safety of others put at risk? Yes, I could have hit a person or car when car accelerated Has the problem been reproduced or confirmed by a dealer or independent service center? No Has the vehicle or component been inspected by the manufacturer, police, insurance representatives or others? No Were there any warning lamps,...
Read the full complaint
messages or other symptoms of the problem prior to the failure, and when did they first appear? A few times car lurch forward when already in park before it happened. Vehicle accelerated violenty and hit an object. Brakes did not properly help me stop the vehicle intially. Car accelerated on it's own. I believe this car is very unsafe and I will not be driving after this incident. I do not believe this vehicle should be sold to anyone else.
On August 4, 2026, I was involved in an accident while driving my 2023 Kia Carnival SX Prestige. During the incident, the brakes felt as though they had locked or frozen. When I attempted to slow down, the vehicle unexpectedly accelerated instead of stopping, resulting in a collision. 1. Component Failure: UNKNOWN. I suspect a malfunction involving the braking system, electronic braking controls, accelerator system, or vehicle control module. The exact cause has not been established. The vehicle should be...
Read the full complaint
available for inspection upon request. 2. Safety Risk: The vehicle did not respond to my attempts to brake and appeared to accelerate unexpectedly. This prevented me from stopping as intended and placed my life and the safety of others on the road at serious risk. 3. Confirmation: UNKNOWN. I have not received a definitive mechanical diagnosis confirming the cause of the malfunction. 4. Inspections: The vehicle sustained substantial damage. Richie Rich Paint & Body provided a preliminary repair estimate of $22,038.07. The GAP administrator reviewed the damage but denied my claim because it did not meet its total-loss percentage requirement. A definitive mechanical investigation has not been provided. 5. Warning Signs: UNKNOWN. I cannot confirm whether warning lights or messages appeared before the incident. The symptoms I experienced were the brakes locking or freezing, followed by unexpected acceleration. I have not been involved in an automobile accident in more than 20 years. I am requesting a comprehensive Kia safety investigation, including examination of the braking and electronic control systems, diagnostic records, and event data recorder. I am concerned that a potential vehicle defect contributed to this accident and request that Kia preserve all available evidence and investigate this matter.
On 8/25/2026 I dropped the vehicle at Plaza Kia, 2699 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11210 (Kia Repair Facility #7119189) for four open recalls: PI2501, PI2602, SC320, and SC368. Brakes were functioning normally at drop-off. Per repair order [[redacted]] dated 8/26/2026, only PI2501 and PI2602 (second-row seat recalls) were performed; SC320 (EGR valve) and SC368 (high-pressure crossover fuel pipe) were not completed - parts on special order. The dealer's multi-point inspection sheet, printed 8/26/2026 12:36 PM, marked...
Read the full complaint
brake fluid level/condition and brake system components as OK/green. The technician time log on the RO shows 0.0 actual hours for that day. The brake lining inspection panels on the sheet are blank. The dealer returned the vehicle to my residence via valet on 8/26/2026. On first use, the brake pedal was extremely hard and stiff with the engine running; the vehicle would only slow with full-force pedal pressure. I nearly collided with a parked vehicle exiting the parking space. I parked and did not drive it further. A vacuum-assist test (pump pedal engine off, hold, start engine) showed the pedal sinking only slightly, and braking under drive felt like engine-off braking - partial or total loss of power assist. Kia Roadside Assistance towed the vehicle to Plaza Kia. Plaza Kia refused to tow it themselves. Plaza Kia has since diagnosed a brake master cylinder failure and stated parts are approximately two weeks out. Repair is under warranty; updated RO pending. Kia Consumer Affairs case #[[redacted]] has been opened. Summary: brake power-assist failure on a 2024 Carnival at ~33,000 miles, occurring in dealer custody or immediately upon return from recall service, on the same day the dealer's inspection cleared the brake system. No prior brake symptoms. INFORMATION REDACTED PURSUANT TO THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT (FOIA), 5 U.S.C. 552(B)(6)
While stopped, the brake pedal drops to the floor and the vehicle begins to roll forward. I went to the dealership and told them what happened, they told me there is no recall on this, and it is a "normal part of driving". This is not a normal part of any braking system. The pedal should not drop to the floor while stopped with your foot on the pedal. No warning system lights that came on. This happens frequently. You have to start pumping the brake repeatedly to get the vehicle to stop. It will eventually raise off the floor.
My 2022 Kia Carnival, approximately 80,000 miles, had intermittent dashboard warning lights and grinding brake noise for a few weeks. I brought the vehicle to Tasca Kia White Plains first time on 4/14/26 then again on 5/8/26. The dealership initially could not reproduce the issue, then later suspected an ABS sensor issue and ordered the part. On 5/12/26, before the repair was completed, I was driving downhill with my children in the vehicle when the brakes failed to respond properly. I had to steer off the roadway...
Read the full complaint
and go over rocks/boulders to stop the vehicle. At that time, the brakes would not respond normally, and I could not immediately shift the vehicle into Park. Police and towing services were involved. The dealership later replaced an ABS sensor. However, when I reviewed the codes with the service manager, I was told the ABS sensor code did not appear on the date of the brake incident. I was also told that an ABS sensor failure itself would not typically cause hydraulic brake failure. I am concerned that the sensor replacement does not explain the brake failure and that this may involve a brake/ABS/electronic stability control safety issue.
The vehicle (2025 Kia Carnival Hybrid) has suffered from a systemic parasitic 12V battery drain since the first month of ownership. The first occurrence was July 20, 2025, requiring a jump-start from Kia Roadside Assistance. On 02/26/2026, the vehicle was presented at Moritz Kia Alliance for the same issue. The dealer diagnosed the 12V battery as defective (Code R04) and replaced it under warranty. However, the defect persisted. On 03/10/2026, only 12 days later, the vehicle suffered another total electrical...
Read the full complaint
failure. I had to utilize Kia Roadside Assistance for a jump-start and drive the vehicle directly to the dealer without turning the engine off to ensure it could be serviced. This marked the second official repair attempt for this recurring defect. The vehicle has remained in dealer possession since March 10 (21 consecutive days). On March 11, only one day after drop-off, the Service Director threatened that the vehicle would be "impounded" after 60 days, despite the vehicle being the subject of an active Texas DMV Lemon Law Case (#26-0012638.CAF). On March 26, a critical safety failure occurred: during a start-up attempt, the Integrated Power Brake (IPB) system malfunctioned, causing the brake pedal to pulsate and physically "kick back" with significant force against my foot. I have serious concerns that this braking failure could occur while in motion, posing an unreasonable risk of high-speed collision, serious injury, or death. No root-cause diagnosis has been made. Furthermore, the main fuse box cover was left off during service, exposing critical electrical components. The vehicle is available for inspection.
ABS was activating inappropriately creating a grinding/pulsating noise while I was attempting to stop at a light. The vehicle did slow down but despite the completely dry road service and sufficient stopping distance, the vehicle never came to a stop and ran into the vehicle in front of me. The vehicle is currently in the autobody shop to be repaired as it is not drivable (leaking fluids). I will be contacting my insurance company and an independent service center shortly to have it inspected. I will also be contacting Kia America, Inc.. There were no warning lamps or symptoms of the problem prior to the failure.
Driver was approaching the end of [[redacted]] and attempted to turn left onto the ramp to [[redacted]] but without prior warning the brakes and the steering wheel failed and he couldn't turn or stop the car which resulted in the vehicle hitting the guardrail. The driver endured injuries on his hand, and overall emotional trauma. My insurance company refused to check the cars computer to prove that the car indeed failed. INFORMATION REDACTED PURSUANT TO THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT (FOIA), 5 U.S.C. 552(B)(6)
Auto hold engaged on car and failed to hold car. Resulted in a crash to my front gate and damage to the car as well as gate. Would not brake when pumping on brake upon collision to front gate. Sensor is now malfunctioning and Kia is not taking responsibility. Most recently the front windshield has a crack that was not caused by anything. Car is parked and covered in my driveway.
Source: U.S. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) complaints and recalls, checked daily. Complaints are owners' own reports and are not verified. How we use the data