Check a vehicle VIN check Latest recalls Latest complaints Common problems Rankings Compare vehicles Recall roundups All makes Guides Share your experience
Theme

2023-2024 · 2 model years

Tesla Model Y (all Variants) Problems by year

Owners have filed 1,538 complaints about the Tesla Model Y (all Variants) across 2 model years, and it has 0 recalls. The 2023 has the most complaints once its age is allowed for (1,198). The most reported problem area is the driver assistance, followed by the steering.

Most complaints for its age20231,198 complaints · 0 recallsSee the 2023
Complaints
1,538
Recalls
0
Crashes
233
Fires
8
Injuries
148
Deaths
1

Model Y (all Variants) complaints by model year

Highlighted: the year with the most complaints for its age. Older vehicles have had more time to collect complaints - the Safety Index grade allows for that.

YearComplaintsRecallsCrashesFiresTop problemGrade
20243400754Driver assistance-
20231,19801584Driver assistance-

Most common Model Y (all Variants) problems

Latest Model Y (all Variants) complaints

2024 Tesla Model Y (all Variants)Brakes

The center rear brake light (third brake light) on my 2024 Tesla Model Y has not worked since at least September 10, 2026. Tesla said it was a VIN-specific software problem and sent an update but the update did not fix it. I have contacted Tesla service centers several times and Tesla keeps telling me to wait. A police officer has warned me about the light. I drive regularly at night and the car remains unrepaired.

Filed Incident Service brakesNHTSA 11777461
2023 Tesla Model Y (all Variants)SteeringElectrical system

While driving a 2023 Tesla Model Y at approximately 45-50 mph on the freeway, the vehicle suffered a severe, uncommanded steering failure. The vehicle violently swerved and oscillated left-right-left without any driver provocation. Autopilot and Full Self-Driving (FSD) were NOT engaged at the time; the car was under manual control. The steering wheel pulled hard and physically yanked out of my hands. I had to manually wrestle the steering wheel for several seconds to regain control and avoid a severe accident....

Read the full complaint

Crucially, there were NO visual warnings on the touchscreen, NO audible safety chimes, and NO error codes displayed during or immediately after the event. Dashcam footage of the incident was captured and saved. The vehicle is being turned over to Tesla Service as unsafe to drive.

Filed Incident Steering · Electrical systemNHTSA 11776371
2024 Tesla Model Y (all Variants)Steering

While driving my 2024 Tesla Model Y, a slight right turn of the steering wheel caused the left front wheel to turn sharply to the right, appearing to reach its full steering angle, while the right front wheel did not turn similarly. The steering was difficult to return to center, with loud clicking/cracking noises. I pulled over safely and stopped driving. After getting out, I observed that the front wheels were pointing at noticeably different angles and recorded a video. The vehicle was unsafe to drive. I...

Read the full complaint

contacted Tesla service and arranged towing through Uber. The cause has not yet been diagnosed. I am concerned that this failure could cause loss of vehicle control, especially at highway speeds.

Filed Incident SteeringNHTSA 11776116
2024 Tesla Model Y (all Variants)Seats & seat belts

The driver side, rear passenger seat buckle, and the middle rear seat buckle, due to work/latch. Tesla is refusing to repair under warranty and charging $160 per seat buckle.

Filed Incident Seat beltsNHTSA 11776029
2024 Tesla Model Y (all Variants)Transmission & drivetrainFuel system

While driving with the vehicle's Full Self-Driving system engaged, my vehicle suddenly displayed a 'Rear Motor Disabled' alert and lost all propulsion, without any prior warning of any kind. The vehicle could not be restarted. I had just exited State Route 134 onto a local road across from Providence High School in Burbank, California, and the vehicle came to a stop in the middle of the roadway, in darkness. Had this failure occurred minutes earlier, while traveling at highway speed at night, the consequences could...

Read the full complaint

have been catastrophic: a vehicle that suddenly loses all propulsion and cannot be restarted becomes a stationary obstacle in fast-moving traffic, in darkness, with no ability to move to the shoulder. Drivers approaching from behind at highway speed would have little time to react, and a rear-end collision - or a multi-vehicle chain collision - would be a likely outcome, with a high risk of serious injury or death. No crash or injury occurred in this incident, but only because of where the failure happened, not because the failure itself was benign. The vehicle's alert screen displayed fault codes DI_a139 (Rear motor disabled) and DIR_a126 and DIR_a062 (Propulsive power reduced). Tesla Service Center has agreed to repair the vehicle under warranty (drive-unit warranty), but no diagnosis has been provided yet. Even once repaired, I have no assurance the underlying cause has been identified or that it will not happen again. The incident occurred at approximately 8:30 PM.

Filed Incident Power train · Fuel / propulsion systemNHTSA 11775242
2023 Tesla Model Y (all Variants)Other & unknownCrash

FSD would not disengage when the brakes were applied and also the steering wheel was turned - doing either is supposed to disengage the self-drive so that you can regain control of the vehicle. I was using the FSD software to drive to a location of a home, I have the settings set to pull into the driveway of the destination. The car started to turn right into the driveway but at the last minute, I decided that I wanted to park on the street. I then turned the wheel to the left which typically disengages the FSD...

Read the full complaint

but instead the car continued to turn right and accelerated and drive into the yard of the destination home and ran over some landscaping. I was wrenching the wheel to the left to get it back on the street to avoid hitting the home itself. I was also hitting the brakes in an attempt to stop the vehicle. Nothing worked. I finally got it back on the street after the vehicle drove down the sidewalk and flattened two mailboxes. It disengaged shortly thereafter. We called Tesla multiple times asking for footage or the car metrics at the time of the accident on [redacted]. We have yet to have the investigation that we have been asking for. When we took the vehicle to a Tesla authorized service in Tucson, they told us we were the third in two weeks that the self-drive did not disengage and a crash followed. This is a risk to the safety of others. This neighborhood I was driving in has a lot of people walking on the sidewalks and I am just fortunate a mailbox was all that the car hit. I have never had anything like this happen. I logged enough hours on FSD to know how to disengage it. The software failed and needs to be investigated. We can't get Tesla to respond or investigate so no one has tried to reproduce what happened but I have never used FSD again after this.

Filed Incident Unknown or otherNHTSA 11775151

Questions about the Tesla Model Y (all Variants)

Which Tesla Model Y (all Variants) years have the most problems?

By the number of complaints owners filed with NHTSA: 2023 (1,198), 2024 (340). Allowing for how long each has been on the road, the 2023 stands out most. Complaint counts also rise with sales, so compare years of the same model rather than different models.

What are the most common Tesla Model Y (all Variants) problems?

Across every model year, owners report problems with the driver assistance (726), steering (245), acceleration & cruise control (205) most often.

How many recalls does the Tesla Model Y (all Variants) have?

NHTSA lists no recalls for any Tesla Model Y (all Variants) model year on file.

Source: U.S. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) complaints and recalls, checked daily. Complaints are owners' own reports and are not verified. How we use the data

Owners helping owners

Know before you drive.

Every experience you share - good or bad - shows on that vehicle's page and helps the next owner and buyer. Two minutes, anonymous.

Share your experience