The brake light switch can fail allowing the switch to remain in the "brake lights off" position or in the "brake lights on" position.
Lights
BMW 525I Lighting problems by year
4 complaints filed with NHTSA about the BMW 525I's lights. Headlights, tail lights, brake lights, turn signals and interior lighting failures.
Lighting complaints by model year
Lighting recalls
Latest 525I lighting complaints
Consumer complained about the low beam headlights. Lights went out without warning. This happened intermittently. *Ak
Tail lights do not stay on due to defective sockets. The plastic sockets have melted from the heat of the tail light bulbs and no longer hold the bulbs in properly. They blink on and off and sometimes stay off all together. Dealer advised me to buy new ones @ $320 each to solve the problem. Since this is a safety defect, bmw should replace them. Dt
Brake light failed no damage, dealer won't honor recall #96v111000. *Ak
BRAKE LIGHTS INOPERATIVE.
Source: U.S. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) complaints and recalls, checked daily. Complaints are owners' own reports and are not verified. How we use the data