Check a vehicle VIN check Latest recalls Latest complaints Common problems Rankings Compare vehicles Recall roundups All makes Guides Share your experience
Theme

Transmission & drivetrain

BMW M5 Transmission problems by year

5 complaints filed with NHTSA about the BMW M5's transmission & drivetrain. Harsh or delayed shifting, slipping, CVT shudder, rollaway, axles, driveshafts and transfer cases.

Transmission complaints by model year

YearTransmission complaintsCrashesInjuriesRecalls
20200001
20190001
20150001
20031000
20024100

Transmission recalls

Latest M5 transmission complaints

2002 BMW M5Transmission & drivetrainBody, doors & structure

There are no power modifications to my vehicle, I just recently installed a lower mileage engine, along with all of the parts surrounding the engine and transmission (ie clutch, flywheel, throwout bearing, clutch fork, etc). The break-in period for a new clutch is 500 miles of normal driving and 1000 miles for the engine. I completed the break-in period on saturday july 20, 2019, for the clutch but still have some miles to go for the engine break-in, so on 7-24-19 I was entering the fwy from a stop light and when I...

Read the full complaint

pushed the gas peadal it sounded like something exploded and I hadn't even gotten out of 1st gear yet!!! So, I pulled over to the side of the road, b/c I heard something rubbing, and called a tow truck to tow it back to the shop that had just installed the new engine. The shop contacted me with news and pictures, showing me that the factory welds on the differential's subframe mount had snapped apart, dropping the differential from its correct position and destroying my driveshaft, in the process. I called bmw of north america and they said there's a recall for the m3 subframe but not the m5??? Then goes on to say with the age and mileage...But welds are supposed to withstand age and mileage, especially being that it's a sports sedan design to shred tyres and achieve 3-digit speeds. The internet is flooded with the very same incidents with other m5 owners but it seems no one else has bothered to voice their concerns b/c if it had not been for the exhaust system then the driveshaft would have dropped to the ground and flipped my car into freeway traffic (see photos)

Filed Incident Power train · StructureNHTSA 11241212
2002 BMW M5Transmission & drivetrainEquipment & accessoriesCrash

Driving at 50 mph I was being harassed by another motorist because I was driving the speed limit. I decided to let him pass but first I had to speed up to 58 mph inorder to completely overtake a passenger car to my right (passenger side) I gave the throttle some gas and the car went nowhere. The needle went all the way into the red zone on the tachometer. The driver behind me (another bmw 3 series),tailgated me. It scared me so bad, that I did not see a deep pot hole in the road surface. I hit it so hard, that I...

Read the full complaint

spun around and all of my wheels were damaged. I had all four wheels repaired and tires at a cost of $2000.The day before, I noticed the service engine soon light was on. Of course, I want this checked out.So I scanned the car. It was displaying 000030 bmw/ or for/ p code p0741 " torque converter clutch valve stuck off .So I went to a bmw dealer. Explained everything. They show me the codes pulled from the car. The code for the tc clutch valve not working was shown.(Their equivalent to p0741) they tell me it is the disa valve.???? Is bmw trying to cover this up?.Disa has zero to do with the torque converter. I see how many have failed and bmw does nothing? I could have been killed. The car did not respond with my request in a manner that affected my well being. If this problem is involved with many, many claims because of a part that is proven to be deficient as it sounds, I am sure if investigated you will find some injuries and/or damages and deaths have occurred and when the dealer sees a bad one, they try to bill it out as something else. I can not be the only one. And why did the bmw dealer try to rip me off? I like my car but the letters bmw put a bad taste in my mouth. Right down to the jerk who tried to run me off of the road. Bmw= ? Anyone else? Anyone who was told something else was bad when it is a bad seal inside the torque converter? *Tr

Filed Incident Power train · Equipment adaptive / mobilityNHTSA 10607249
2003 BMW M5SuspensionTransmission & drivetrain

I backed my 2003 bmw m5 out of the drive way and heard a terrible sound, I attempted to drive the car forward, and the noise got worse. I returned the car to the drive way and put it on jacks and stands to find the noise. I discovered that the rear subframe was broken (i have pictures and will be getting the original parts back for testing) from the mount holding it to the frame. I have researched forums for 1999-2004 bmw 5 series cars and have located 14 more people that have suffered the same fate (is has...

Read the full complaint

happened in 528, 540, and m5 models from 1999-2004). The repair is costing me approximately $4000.00. If this break had occurred at highway speed the drive shaft and differential would have separated and would been free to fly around and cause severe damage to the car and anyone in it. *Tr

Filed Incident Suspension · Power trainNHTSA 10513279
2002 BMW M5Engine & coolingTransmission & drivetrainEquipment & accessories

My bmw m3ci is again in the shop. In the last 23k miles, the car has seen the shop more than anyone's imagination. Now the engine revs high at idle, transmission light (smg 2 of m3) came on, which no one seems to know why, and mysteriously disappeared. The car now vibrate trhough out the cabin and at steering wheel it vibrates abnormally. The dealer tries to down play it. It's been in th shop for the last 14 days, and still no ending insight

Filed Incident Engine and engine cooling · Power train · EquipmentNHTSA 10069835

Source: U.S. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) complaints and recalls, checked daily. Complaints are owners' own reports and are not verified. How we use the data

Owners helping owners

Know before you drive.

Every experience you share - good or bad - shows on that vehicle's page and helps the next owner and buyer. Two minutes, anonymous.

Share your experience