Check a vehicle VIN check Latest recalls Latest complaints Common problems Rankings Compare vehicles Recall roundups All makes Guides Share your experience
Theme

Engine & cooling

2008 Mini Clubman S Engine problems

Owners have filed 43 complaints about the 2008 Mini Clubman S's engine & cooling with NHTSA - 60% of all its complaints, most recently on June 17, 2020. They describe 0 crashes, 5 fires and 0 injuries. Stalling, loss of power, oil consumption, overheating, head gaskets, timing chains and engine failure.

Complaints
43
Recalls
0
Crashes
0
Fires
5
Injuries
0
Deaths
0

Engine complaints

Engine & coolingFuel system

I purchased a 2008 clubman and it's the non-turbo but the engine has an issue with multiple misfire codes being sent out to the obd2 reader as well as some ecu codes that imply weak fuel pressure and when looking up and trying to find how to replace the fuel pressure pump then I realized I was not alone in this issue and wonder if anyone else has had the thought to actually file a complaint so that way something can be done since it's a very faulty thing and most of these have had issues from 30000 miles about but...

Read the full complaint

then for all the others that also have it after the warranty drops to intentionally put in a faulty part I'm not sure if it's illegal or not but it should be. I do no that if they put in enough faulty parts there should be a recall made if it is determined that they are at fault and not the people buying them or mistreating or not maintaining etc etc... I strongly urge anyone else that's had this issue to also make your own complaint if it has happened to you, especially if you had to buy a new car because of it. *Tr

Filed Incident Engine · Fuel / propulsion systemNHTSA 11329486
Engine & cooling

My 2008 mini cooper s clubman appears to be having a problem with the tim ing chain tensioner and timing chain. The noise is steadily getting worse. After reading about the class action lawsuits around the united states I am now afraid to drive the car. If the timing chain desires to come apart on the freeway the sudden loss of steering and brakes could cause a major accident by engine seizing up if the timing chain let's go. Also the damage to the engine would cost so much it would not be worth fixing.Leaving us with a $7500 owed on a vehicle we cannot use.

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 11060861
Engine & cooling

Car has just over 100000 miles but has been constantly overheating (have to fill tank almost every day). Cannot find out the source, but I noticed a recall on the water pump on other similar models, but vin search said mine was okay. I feel this is an error. Please inform me of my next step. Getting very frustrated. I wouldn't consider this high mileage for this car, and I take care of it.

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 11012947
Engine & cooling

While driving on a city street, I was stopped in traffic. I pulled off in first gear and the car died. Several other drivers helped me push my car to a safe lot.I then had the car checked out to find the timing chain broke and ruined the engine. I bought the car through car max with their pre owned, pre certified program. My car now has 80,000 miles as it has since march 10th 2017. I'm still making payments and full coverage insurance payments on a car I can't drive. Do I have any recourse? Are automobile...

Read the full complaint

manufacturers not held accountable. Under different circumstances, I could have died or been seriously injured that day. This is widespread. There are literally 100s of thousands of mini owners with the exact same issue. The timing tensioner breaks causing the timing chain to give way. God forbid this happens at highway speeds. England has recalled all their mini coopers a repaired them. What about america! Sincerely,[[redacted]] information redacted pursuant to the freedom of information act (foia), 5 u.S.C. 552(B)(6). *Tr

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 10992812
Engine & cooling

I have had major problems with my engine ever since I have had my mini cooper s clubman. The turbo is loose, there is oil burning off of my engine, and it makes terrible screeching sounds that come from the engine. I have just learned that it is common for a mini cooper to have problems with its timing chain; thus, causing this terrible sound and all those other problems. I did not know it was the timing chain, and now they are having a recall on most of there models that are from the same year as mine. My car...

Read the full complaint

whenever I brake makes screeching noises that come from my engine, and I'm worried that this poor engine design will cause me to get in an accident. Now I have to pour money into getting a new timing chain, even though mini cooper is now know for having terrible timing chains.

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 10969964
Engine & cooling

I took my car in for a service engine soon warning light. The engine was/is burning oil. The mini staff told me that this was a design flaw with this engine. I need to check my oil level every week or whenever I fill up. Keep putting in more oil when the level gets low. I have spent a lot of money for their design flaw. No offer from mini about replacing the engine. Mini told me to write to hq, which I have but nothing has come of it. I am tired of paying for their design flaw and I don't think I should have to pay for their mistake.

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 10969354
Acceleration & cruise controlEngine & cooling

I was driving down the highway, and there was no acceleration of my car, the valves were clattering and had no power. *Tr

Filed Incident Vehicle speed control · EngineNHTSA 10946175
Engine & cooling

Timing chain jumped off of dead center. Had to replace timing chair to new upgraded assembly. Cost was around $1200.00. Upset because this has been happening to a lot of mini coopers. Should have some kind of recall to consumers. Bmw knows about this.Was driving home from out of state.

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 10893396
Engine & cooling

The timing chain was replaced at 90,000 mile and and now need to be replaced at 104,000 miles

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 10860688
Engine & cooling

Timing chain guide is made out of plastic. It broke apart and fell in pieces into the oil pan. It caused the engine to seize and the vehicle was completely inoperable.

Filed Incident Engine and engine coolingNHTSA 10859741
Engine & cooling

Leaking turbo oil feed line. Oil feed line leaks oil causing smoke and strong smell.

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 10839583
Engine & cooling

The timing chain assembly is failing after having the car for less than 5,000 miles after buying it used from a mini dealership who had performed their usual inspections and resale maintenance. Apparently the timing chain is inside the engine casing and the metal chain runs along a plastic guide. The top portion of the plastic guide has, it appears, failed, causing a very loud engine noise and risking complete timing failure which, of course, could potentially present serious mechanical and safety issues if it...

Read the full complaint

happens at high speed. I have found wide reports of this happening similarly in other cars, however after a quick search, I don't see this issue listed on this nhtsa site, so I thought it should be added. See these links for reference: http://www.Consumeraffairs.Com/news/consumers-complain-of-mini-cooper-timing-belt-failures-080113.Html and http://blog.Autoworkstx.Com/2014/10/mini-cooper-timing-chain-issues/

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 10764078
AirbagsEngine & coolingFuel system

Vehicle started having trouble turning on and when it did come on a loud clanking noise began. The car could barely go over 30mph. 3 Hr. Drive took us almost 6 hours to get to dealership. Dealership states it is the timing chain and the oil pan needs to be replaced.We found excessive water in the spare wheel hub. The brake light sensor would not go off, airbag light appeared, a knocking noise in the gas tank consisted. Etc.

Filed Incident Air bags · Engine · Fuel / propulsion systemNHTSA 10731817
Engine & cooling

The car developed engine trouble at 51,934 miles. We called otto's mini dealership and were told that the car was no longer under warranty. We then took car to a local repair shop and were told that the engine needed replacing due to faulty timing chain that resulted in extensive damage to the cylinder head and pistons. Upon researching this problem it appears that it is very common. We proceeded with the repair at the local shop and filed with mini to request coverage. Coverage was denied since we did not have car serviced at the dealer. The nature of this repair and the large number of reported issues would suggest one to expect mini to stand behind their product. *Tr

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 10678763
Engine & cooling

The oil supply line to the turbo on this car leaks due to a poor design. The part(s) used by the manufacturer are not suitable for the application and fail, causing not only an oil leak, but a potential turbo failure, and worse, the potential for an engine fire, as the oil leaks onto a hot turbo charger and exhaust manifold/downpipe. The oil line uses a compression fitting where it attaches to the turbo body. This fitting uses an internal rubber o-ring/seal that is subjected to high heat, and heat cycles every...

Read the full complaint

time the car is run. Rubber seals fail under these conditions! The manufacturer (mini/bmw) is aware of the problem, and is doing nothing to correct it. (It's very expensive repair) instead, the manufacturer is providing a "band-aid fix" by supplying a "heat shield" that attaches to the fitting. This will do little-to-nothing to prevent the rubber o-ring from failing, nor does it fix a line that is already leaking. This failure occurs, typically, after the car is out of warranty. It's a serious design flaw, and should be a recall item due to the safety issue it creates. *Tr

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 10671191
Engine & cooling

The bango fitting on top of the turbo started randomly and excessively leaking oil while idling in my driveway. Could have caused a fire. Going to have to replace the oil intake line, oil, and do a engine cleaning. This is very dangerous and could have easily started a fire with oil pouring over a hot turbo. *Tr

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 10669836
Engine & cooling

I was hearing a loud rattle and brought my mini in to get serviced right away. It was misdiagnosed and now I fear it has caused significant damage to the engine due to a timing chain tensioner issue. The car will lose power out of nowhere. I have read that this is not being considered a safety issue but when you live in minnesota and are trying to go through a busy intersection during a blizzard and the car loses all power and you almost get t-boned by a truck I would tend to disagree. *Tr

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 10664266
Engine & cooling

While driving home on secondary road, a loud engine noise started and the engine light came on blinking. I pulled over and had car towed to my garage. The diagnosis was that the timing chain tensioner broke and had to be repaird. This was done for a cost of $567.97. In researching information about this, it appears many owners have had the same problem. I am filing this complaint in hopes that bmw reimburses this expense for an issue they seem to be aware of but are not taking recall action with. *Tr

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 10648667
Engine & cooling

We started our 2008 mini clubman s in a parking lot and it immediately indicated a check engine light (cel) for 'limp' mode. Upon further inspection, the upper guide rail for the timing chain had shattered. The odbii codes were p0300, random mis-fire, p0301 mis-fire cylinder 1, p0303 mis-fire cylinder 3 and p1492, downstream throttle air leak. *Tr

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 10608012
Engine & cooling

I am deaf I drive my 2008 mini clubman s my mother , brother and friend heard my engine noise engine ,i don't know I can't hear so I open oil cap I saw brown plastic piece I found timing chain guide is bad, that is short life that is wrong. *Tr

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 10577750
Engine & cooling

In november the dealer informed me my oil feed lines to the turbo were leaking and would need to be replaced soon. After doing some research I have found the couplings that attaches these lines to the turbo are defective. On the internet there are hundreds of complaints about this issue. The dealer says there is not a recall and will cost approx: $1200.00. The dealer also said the new couplings are manufactured by a new company and the defect has been fixed. With so many effective shouldn't mini be fixing this issue. *Tr

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 10574919
Engine & cooling

I was a victim of the "death rattle" from the timing chain tensioner failure. Luckily for me, I researched the noise when I first heard it and was able to get it fixed before it destroyed my entire engine (although mini refused to pay for the repairs). But owners who are not aware of issue may keep driving their car to the point of failure which could lead to a fatal crash. It is a poorly manufactured part that is creating the problem which can be easily fixed. *Tr

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 10568041
Engine & cooling

Thermostat failure, as diagnosed by dealer. Car undriveable. World wide bac korder on the part for 2007-2010 mini coopers. No known date of when the part will be available (or if) and the dealer in bedford nh, stated over 17,000 of these parts are on backorder. A failed thermostat can lead to stranded motorists, engine overheating and extensive engine damage. This part is notorious for premature failure. Should this not be a recallable issue? *Jb

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 10542036
Electrical systemBrakesEngine & coolingFire

Playing golf, car is in parking lot. Engine catches fire, destroyed front half of car, engine fell on pavement . *Tr

Filed Incident Electrical system · Service brakes · EngineNHTSA 10534785
Transmission & drivetrainEngine & cooling

While driving up an incline on a semi-rural road in orange county, ca, my car appeared to be unable to shift gears (it is an automatic transmission). My head lurched forward and back again forcefully, and I was unable to drive more than 20 mph on a 60 mph speed limit road for the next mile, until I arrived at my destination. Luckily no one was close behind me, or I could have been rear-ended, and luckily I was close to my final destination. I drive a 2008 mini cooper clubman s, automatic with paddle shifters. It is about $8,300 to $9,700 to repair it (2 different repair quotes obtained). *Tr

Filed Incident Power train · EngineNHTSA 10532089

Mini Clubman S engine complaints by year

Clubman S engine problems, every year

Had a engine problem with your 2008 Clubman S? Tell other owners.

Your experience goes live straight away and helps every owner and buyer who checks this vehicle. Anonymous, free, no account.

Overall, how would you rate it? *

0/4000 · Please leave out names, phone numbers and your full VIN.

By posting you confirm it's your own, honest experience and agree to the rules. Safety defect? Also report it to NHTSA - that's how recalls start.

Source: U.S. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) complaints and recalls, checked . Complaints are owners' own reports and are not verified. How we use the data

Owners helping owners

Know before you drive.

Every experience you share - good or bad - shows on that vehicle's page and helps the next owner and buyer. Two minutes, anonymous.

Share your experience