Check a vehicle VIN check Latest recalls Latest complaints Common problems Rankings Compare vehicles Recall roundups All makes Guides Share your experience
Theme

Wheels & tires

Subaru Legacy Tire problems by year

136 complaints filed with NHTSA about the Subaru Legacy's wheels & tires. Tire failures, tread separation, wheel bearings, lug nuts, rims and tire pressure monitoring.

Tire complaints by model year

YearTire complaintsCrashesInjuriesRecalls
20241000
20221000
20201000
20192000
20183000
20173000
20164100
20153000
20122000
20113000
20102000
20092000
20084000
20072000
20062000
200512220
20041000
20035001
20025100
200111100
200018100
19997300
19988000
19976000
19963000
19958000
19942110
19938000
19925100
19911000
19901000

Tire recalls

Latest Legacy tire complaints

2018 Subaru LegacyElectrical systemWheels & tiresBrakes

I front passenger window stop working and does not roll up and down. I had this issue and reported the issue since I bought it brand new from the lot. I main main audio console has been replacement 2 times already from defectives. My tires TMPS is flashing now but my tire pressure are fine. My incline break button comes on by itself from time to time and does not allow for me to move the car.

Filed Incident Electrical system · Wheels · Service brakesNHTSA 11682969
2001 Subaru LegacyWheels & tires

Headed home from a vet appointment in mountain home. Was driving on the freeway at 80mph when the tire blew at the Wendell exit. Checked the tire to find that the inside wall had failed and had a blowout. The tire was installed June 8th 2025 and had less than 1,000 miles on it. I have never in 26 years of being around vehicles had a brand new tire fail in less than 1,000 miles. Tire was a good year reliant all season 195/65/R15. That tire blowout could have killed me and my family. I stopped at the Walmart that I...

Read the full complaint

bought the tire from with the receipt and was told "oh that sucks. We can replace it for you if you want to buy a new one a full price." How can a company sell a tire from a brand like good year that isn't even covered for a 1,000 miles? That's absolutely mind blowing. Had anyone gotten injured from the accident I would filling charges against Walmart for selling me a faulty tire

Filed Incident TiresNHTSA 11673162
2022 Subaru LegacyWheels & tires

The first tire had an air bubble and I brought it in. They said it was a manufacturer error. In September 2023 I had a blowout and Subaru declared that it was a manufacturer defect. I asked him to check all the tires and they kept the original set on. This month a third tire from the original set blew while being driven. Three tires out of four have had manufacturer defects.

Filed Incident TiresNHTSA 11603654
2020 Subaru LegacyWheels & tires

While driving on freeway the tire pressure warning light came on. I started to slow down and pull over and I felt the car wobble. I pulled to the side of the road and the tire had completely failed. The sidewalls, inside and out, had square chunks completely gone along the complete sidewall.

Filed Incident TiresNHTSA 11557557
2019 Subaru LegacyWheels & tires

After my 2019 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Limited sat outside on a level blacktop parking lot for one week (05-03-23 to 05-10-23) without moving, both passenger side tires were discovered completely deflated. The tires were Goodyear Eagle LS-2 size 225/50R18 95H (front passenger DOT M678 JR2R 1819 and rear passenger DOT M678 JR2R 1719). The tires were original to the car when purchased new by myself at Jenkins Subaru in Bridgeport WV on 09-23-19 with 26 miles on the odometer. The tires had 32,515 miles on them and were...

Read the full complaint

rotated 6 times. Sever dry rot on the tires sidewalls was the reason given by the Goodyear technician, Goodyear Service Center, 149 Green Bag Rd, Morgantown, WV, 304296-1748, for complete deflation. It was also recommended that the remaining divers side tires be replaced as they were also displaying sidewall dry rot (front drivers DOT M678 JR2R 1719 and rear drivers DOT M678 JR2R 1819). All four tires were replaced with new Goodyear Eagle LS2 tires (2 on 05-10-23 and 2 on 05-12-23).

Filed Incident TiresNHTSA 11521859
2016 Subaru LegacyWheels & tires

This concern is not related to the VIN number listed. I Have concerns with Aftermarket wheels in general. as the service manager of a shop I am seeing aftermarket wheels that are cracking under normal use due to poor metal quality and design. I have seen dual bolt pattern wheels that crack at the lug nut mounting hole when torquing to the vehicle manufacture spec. I have seen many aftermarket wheels installed with incorrect lug nuts and incorrect or missing hub centric devices. I Believe that the public does not understand the safety concerns of aftermarket wheels.

Filed Incident WheelsNHTSA 11514390
2006 Subaru LegacyWheels & tires

Hub was replaced in June of 2019. Car was driven about 14,000 miles (estimate) since then. While driving down the road, I hard a noise on the front right tire. When I pulled the hub cap off, two bolts were sheared off, one nut was loose. I checked the torque on the remaining two bolts, and it was about 80 ft-lbs, which is what is specified in the manual. Since I torque all 5 in star order (twice) when I change tires, there is no change they were under or over torqued. Tires were changed twice a year by myself, so...

Read the full complaint

nuts went on/off four times since installing the hub. No other failures on any other studs, on two subaru cars that I followed the same practices on. I used a press to press out the studs (as pictured), but due to a defective design, the studs can't be removed without pressing out the bearing and separating the halves. Additionally the replacement studs I bought are a larger diameter, and have a shoulder that would have protected against this failure. As such this looks like a defective design. It's not an OEM replacement, it does not last a reasonable time, and presents a real risk of losing a tire at speed on a car. Manufacturer phone number as listed on Amazon is disconnected. Their web site is broken, and does not allow "chat" to work. Their listed phone number refused to allow a connection unless the dialer states their age, which makes it sound like a scam number. They claim a 10 year warranty, but want me to call them to process. Apparently I cannot do so, as they have made it impossible.

Filed Incident WheelsNHTSA 11488056
2017 Subaru LegacyWheels & tires

Tire size - 225/50r19. My 2017 subaru legacy has approximately 17,000 miles. As I hand wash my car I noticed that all 4 tires have significant cracks on the sidewall. I'm concerned about driving my car on the highway and I often pick-up our 3 grandchildren from school which also concerns me. These are my observations but I've also read a few similar issues on the goodyear website but they referred to the problem as dry rot? Thank god no accidents or flats but I have problems with the tires losing air. I just want piece of mind and I will go to a goodyear tire dealer soon to get their opinion. Hope to hear back from you shortly. Thank you!

Filed Incident TiresNHTSA 11463740
2018 Subaru LegacyWheels & tires

225/50R18. Factory OEM, serious dry-rot necessitating replacement due to safety concerns. Tires are slightly older than 3.5 years (2018 model year purchased 04/18) with less than 40k miles. All four tires exhibit the dry rot, but the photo is representative of the most serious case of concern. No concerns related to tread wear depth.

Filed Incident TiresNHTSA 11435634
2018 Subaru LegacyWheels & tires

P225 / 50 R 18 On 8/28/2021, I noticed my front drivers tired looked weird. Upon inspection, it looked like dry rot. I do have a picture of the tire. I immediately went to Tire Kingdom and purchased a set of of 4 new tires. Tire Kingdom confirmed that the tire looked defective. Still plenty of tread, but the side was separating causing it to not be safe. There was no warning on the car system as the tire had not yet completely separated.

Filed Incident TiresNHTSA 11431524
2015 Subaru LegacyWheels & tires

Especially, while driving on the highway, I could hear the unusual spinning of the wheels. It happened about a year ago, and when I brought it to the attention of the front desk clerk at the quality subaru in wallingford, ct., He informed me that he will let the technician know. He never wrote anything regarding my concerns on the slip with the oil change information. The technician said, that he did not see anything wrong with it, it could be the surface of the highway or my tires. I purchased new tires, install...

Read the full complaint

new brakes and the noise was still there. On february 25, 2020, I went through another multipoint inspection, and this time, the technician found both rear wheel bearings noisy and recommended replacing them for $1155.Oo plus tax and my car had 69057 miles. My complaint is that the same noise was there about a year ago when my car was 55000 miles and I kind of used to this noise. Please make a note of it. Thank you.

Filed Incident WheelsNHTSA 11321574
2019 Subaru LegacyWheels & tires

I had 4,000 miles goodyear eagle ls2 tires when I experienced a sidewalk blowout on the expressway in another state. We had to have it replaced while traveling. The repair shop said it was suspect since there wasn't a foreign object or puncture, it was just the sidewall that blew out. There were no potholes around. Fast forward 5 months and another tire developed a bulge in the sidewall. I happened to notice it when I was at the gas station. Luckily it didn't blow out. I have never experienced any tire ever blowing...

Read the full complaint

out or bulging in all the miles I drive. I'm on the road almost every day for my sales job. To me this seems like a quality issue. I still have the second tire if you would like to look at it. The authorized dealer I took it to couldn't be bothered with a warranty issue. There was no damage to my wheel at all and I didn't hit a pothole or road debris.

Filed Incident WheelsNHTSA 11281199
2016 Subaru LegacyWheels & tires

Need to replace goodyear eagle ls2 225/50r18 tires. 4 Of them have dry rot on the inside of the tire closest to the rim. One has a bubble on the inside. Car just turned 37 thousand miles yesterday. This is a potential issue to continue driving on these tires. I am afraid of a blowout

Filed Incident Tires · Wheels · Unknown or otherNHTSA 11221393
2012 Subaru LegacyWheels & tires

Cpsc: our 2012 subaru legacy while parked in our garage was found with two flat tires at same time. One tire on passenger front was catastrophic failure as 2 major holes were in sidewall from huge blowout and rear passenger tire had bulge in sidewall leaking air. *Dt the consumer stated the brand of tires were pirelli p4 season p215/60r16 95t sl bsw. *Js *tr*jb

Filed Incident Tires · Unknown or otherNHTSA 11217959

Source: U.S. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) complaints and recalls, checked daily. Complaints are owners' own reports and are not verified. How we use the data

Owners helping owners

Know before you drive.

Every experience you share - good or bad - shows on that vehicle's page and helps the next owner and buyer. Two minutes, anonymous.

Share your experience