Check a vehicle VIN check Latest recalls Latest complaints Common problems Rankings Compare vehicles Recall roundups All makes Guides Share your experience
Theme

Transmission & drivetrain

2005 Mini Cooper Transmission problems

Owners have filed 50 complaints about the 2005 Mini Cooper's transmission & drivetrain with NHTSA - 6% of all its complaints, most recently on February 18, 2022. Harsh or delayed shifting, slipping, CVT shudder, rollaway, axles, driveshafts and transfer cases.

Complaints
50
Recalls
0
Crashes
0
Fires
0
Injuries
0
Deaths
0

Transmission complaints

Transmission & drivetrain

The transmission will cycle first through third and when it tries to go into 4th it slips and will not operate higher gears it caused me to lose my forward drive momentum as I was switching lanes and the car I was getting in front of almost ran into me.

Filed Incident Power trainNHTSA 11452775
Transmission & drivetrainAcceleration & cruise control

When driving vehicle transmission slips causing a jerk reaction in the vehicle and then it will renegade causing another jerk reaction in the vehicle and makes going and or stopping unpredictable. Turning left is dangerous as the car may not move forward at a speed that it should or may jerk in the middle causing the vehicle to stop in front of oncoming traffic. I have had a machanic change the transmission and it still does the same thing. I have contacted the manufacturers who informed me that there were no recalls and nothing they would do.

Filed Incident Power train · Vehicle speed control · Unknown or otherNHTSA 11397204
SteeringTransmission & drivetrainBrakes

The power steering assist has all but stopped working, with steering now difficult at lower speed--especially when I first start the engine in the morning. The clutch doesn't respond well and the vehicle no longer goes into second gear. The rear left brake caliper seized in place, not allowing the brake pad to retract completely and therefore the brake pad continuously rubbed against the disc, but without noise. Not until the left rear brake made noise because of the metal on metal braking was the seized oem caliper identified, when I put on a set of new brake pads. None of the other three brakes had the seized oem caliper.

Filed Incident Steering · Power train · Service brakesNHTSA 11311300
Transmission & drivetrain

Before I bought the car it was rear-ended from losing speed because the transmission was slipping. This is in the design of this year of mini cooper as I am finding that it is on the internet as just a bad design. I can't get anyone to work on it for a reasonable price. I'm hoping there's some help out there for unsuspecting innocent people like me who thought they were getting a good car and now it is just unsafe as I have had to tow it 3 times now and I've only had it since may of this year 2018.

Filed Incident Power trainNHTSA 11114462
Transmission & drivetrain

Transmission upshifts and downshifts erratically and/or shifts into neutral without driver input while in motion.

Filed Incident Power trainNHTSA 10956757
Transmission & drivetrain

Takata recall. Transmission would not shift gears intermittently while in automatic. Spent $5,600 to rebuild transmission. Still having intermittent issues.

Filed Incident Power trainNHTSA 10910754
Transmission & drivetrainAirbags

Front driver seat occupant detection mat doesn't seem to be working correctly as it doesn't detect sometimes when there is an occupant. Second issue is the cvt transmission of this vehicle. I get a jerking motion every now and then and found a class action lawsuit linked with these transmissions. I purchased this car after this lawsuit but apparently this particular vehicle was not taken care of. My vehicle only has 70,000 miles on it and find this unacceptable.

Filed Incident Power train · Air bagsNHTSA 10884074
Transmission & drivetrain

Transmission previously replaced at 48k miles by manufacturer due to noise. My transmission is broken. My tires chirp every time I push on the gas because the transmission does not know what gear to be in due to the bad body control valve. The transmission needs to be replaced because I cannot verify how much mechanical damage has taken place during the time that the valve body has been broken. Once the valve body breaks down, the mechanical unit also begins to break down. Mini needs to issue a service bulletin...

Read the full complaint

telling the dealers to commence servicing the aisin transmissions every 40k by replacing the fluid. Bmw/mini's transmission fluid is not lifetime. Volkswagen issued a similar bulletin a few years ago because it also uses the aisin transmission. The independent repair shops may not replace the fluid right because the transmission fluid is hard to drain and in many cases if it's not done right, great damage is done the engine. The consumer stated the vehicle was under powered upon acceleration. The vehicle would jerk, and buck. The valve body in the transmission began to break down because the shavings from the transmission gears began to cloud the fluid and inhibit communication from the valve body solenoids to the mechanical components. Updated 03/23/16.*Jb

Filed Incident Power trainNHTSA 10826000
SteeringTransmission & drivetrain

Tl* the contact owns a 2005 mini cooper. The contact stated that the power steering failed and the transmission was leaking fluid. The vehicle was taken to the dealer where it was diagnosed that the power steering pump, fan, and the transmission needed to be replaced. The power steering was repaired at a cost of $1900. The manufacturer was made aware of the failure. The failure mileage was 64,200. Updated 7/1/15*cn updated 07/09/15*jb

Filed Incident Steering · Power trainNHTSA 10715169
Transmission & drivetrain

My 2005 mini cooper convertible needs the transmission replaced. My car has only 92,000 miles and it is unfair that already it has to be replace at a ridiculous cost. There was a class action law suit with bmw/mini for the transmission that went wrong. There are many people besides myself who where not notified of this and were left out. Mini cooper should recall the transmissions .There are many forums of mini cooper owners who are outraged and have similar situations. Please consider and make this company recall the transmissions. Thank you *tr

Filed Incident Power trainNHTSA 10670215
Transmission & drivetrain

The transmission in this vehicle is known to be defective by mini usa. The car is undrivable and unsafe as the transmission could fail at any time, stranding the driver or causing a fire. *Tr

Filed Incident Power trainNHTSA 10574290
Engine & coolingTransmission & drivetrain

Around june 2008 my mini cooper s 2005 began exhibiting what appeared to be a failure to maintain consistent speed while driving at a constant rpm. I experienced slow, or sluggish acceleration while driving and the engine light would come on sporadically. I took my mini, which was still under warranty in for service to bmw/mini of san antonio and was reassured that I was experiencing normal shifting mechanics. They were also unable to detect why the engine light was coming on. I experienced these idiosyncratic...

Read the full complaint

issues continuously throughout the year and began to notice the car jumping higher and lower in speed during acceleration in more regular intervals. In september of 2010 the engine would lurch into gear, seconds after failing to change gears effectively. At times, the car would suddenly drop out of gear while driving. I began taking my car into a bmw/mini certified shop in austin, tx. After much time, money, and trouble, plus many visits to the mechanic, my mini cooper's condition deteriorated completely. While in busy traffic my mini lurched forward and stalled coming to a complete stop while driving before I could get it off the busy roadway. I was almost rear ended by vehicles behind mine, these drivers had to make extreme evasive maneuvers in order not to hit me, the car in front of them, or be rear ended themselves. This unsafe and hazardous incident endangered my life, and was the last for my mini, resulting in complete transmission failure in july 2011. I sought opinions on my options, shop quotes to fix my vehicle, all around $10,000. My vehicle has not been fixed or altered, it stands as it did the day of the transmission failure. It was towed from the shop to storage. My vehicle is no longer under warranty, and there are many others who have similar circumstance documented. Why was there no recall? Class action lawsuits in california and new jersey. *Tr

Filed Incident Engine and engine cooling · Power trainNHTSA 10563887
Transmission & drivetrain

When my mini cooper s convertible only had around 85,000 mile on speedometer my transmission would suddenly have difficulty going from 3rd to 4th gear and stall while going down the road and I have almost been rear ended by cars behind me not expecting me to stall. Upon researching web there are many same complaints about this model vehicle. It is a safety issue. Mini usa did not agree to fix the vehicle. I think this should be addressed as a recall before some one is killed. *Tr

Filed Incident Power trainNHTSA 10549548
Transmission & drivetrain

The automatic cvt transmission just down shifted and now won't go into high gear. This will happen on the freeway and will shift and clunk into gear. Bmw is aware of the problem with this transmission but won't stand behind their product. It is very dangerous to drive. *Js

Filed Incident Power trainNHTSA 10545535
Transmission & drivetrain

Problem with automatic transmission on 2005 mini cooper s. Needs replacement $8000+. Only 90k miles. Hundreds of complaints on line regarding cvt transmission defect. Mini cooper/ bmw not admitting problem to public. *Tr

Filed Incident Power trainNHTSA 10504719
Transmission & drivetrainAcceleration & cruise controlEngine & cooling

When accelerating from 30 to 40 miles an hour/shifting from 3rd to 4th gear, my transmission would rev up the rpms and my car no longer accelerates. It went from about 2 to 5.5 Rpms, even after I took my foot off the gas pedal. Once it finally does shift, it lurches the car forward violently. It takes a while for the transmission to start acting up, but once the car is fully warmed up, it seems nearly impossible to have it not happen. It's even more frustrating and frightening because I do all city driving, where...

Read the full complaint

I slow down and speed up so I am constantly having to get within the 30mph range. My car stops accelerating so I am afraid of my transmission dying in the middle of traffic or slowing down so much that is causes an accident. Bottom line: my car does not function properly and potentially endangers me, so I am afraid to drive my car. *Tr

Filed Incident Power train · Vehicle speed control · EngineNHTSA 10504694
Transmission & drivetrain

I am the current owner of a 2005 mini cooper s. I purchased the vehicle in 2006 from mini of irvine with 3,000 miles. I have recently been experiencing issues with the cvt transmission. The car jerks when changing gears at any speed, as well as when switching from drive to reverse. I have taken the car to mini of san diego to be diagnosed and have been notified that the transmission needs to be replaced at a cost of $8,000. The vehicle currently has 73,000 miles and find it completely unacceptable that the transmission is failing so early on. *Tr

Filed Incident Power trainNHTSA 10504190
Transmission & drivetrainBody, doors & structure

Traveling at approximately 40mph. Finger was cut 2mm deep by defective peeling/flaking chrome accent on manual transmission shift knob. As a result, finger was bleeding and experienced a shock from the affected nerve throughout the body while vehicle was in motion. Attention to the road was lost for a moment causing me to nearly get into an accident. *Tr

Filed Incident Power train · StructureNHTSA 10490175
Transmission & drivetrainElectrical systemEngine & cooling

Started vehicle in the morning of 11/14/2012. The shift indicator on the dash shows ep mode instead of d,r,n,etc. The car seemed to drive fine but there's something wrong with the shifter electronics. The car does not seem to know what drive mode is in. Putting the auto manual transmission into sports mode does not change the shift indicator on the dash. In sports modes it still showed ep. In ep mode the car does not rev beyond 3000rpm and drives rough at certain speeds. This may be a manufacturer defect with a transmission sensor, or the shifter electronics. *Tr

Filed Incident Power train · Electrical system · EngineNHTSA 10488703
Transmission & drivetrainEngine & cooling

At low miles the transmission has to be replaced. No fore warning just gone. I'm trying to drive and at 10 mph I'm revving at up to 3000 rpm's. This should def not be happening! I'm fuming being that I have to now replace the transmission when I have not beaten on it or anything to make this happen. So far my experience with bmw has not been good. I would have been better buying anything else. *Tr

Filed Incident Power train · EngineNHTSA 10487188
Transmission & drivetrain

I had a little whining sound when I pushed on the clutch. Everything worked fine even with the whining sound. I started driving to the mechanics and my car completely shut down. The transmission came completely apart. All the teeth are gone from the second gear with no warning. I have already spent 2000.00, Now I will have to either spend another 3000.00 For a new transmission, or trade in my car at a horrible loss and I will be upside down on the next car. I read that there were class action lawsuits against mini/bmw over the transmissions. I was hoping that I would find a recall on here. *Tr

Filed Incident Power trainNHTSA 10485829
Transmission & drivetrain

The transmission on our 2005 mini had been slipping but we could not afford to have it fixed. My daughter was driving to various local shopping plazas applying for jobs. She could not have been driving over 45 mph because that was the maximum speed one could drive without the transmission slipping out of gear. The car began to make a whirring sound and smoke. She pulled into a parking lot and safely parked. The engine continued to smoke and all of the transmission fluid leaked onto the ground. We had the vehicle towed to our home and it now sits in our garage while we continue to pay for it and insure it. *Tr

Filed Incident Power trainNHTSA 10481370
Transmission & drivetrain

After driving one evening a short distance to the store and feeling a strange pulling of the car but not really moving as fast as it should, I took it to be checked out at the mini of the lehigh valley. I was told that it was a faulty transmission but that I could still continue to drive it short distances. This cost $138. So after a couple of short trips to work, I was on my way home on monday september 10th when it started to "shut down", it was revving very loudly but only moving at about 20mph at the most....

Read the full complaint

I had to pull over many times due to anxiety, fear and causing an accident. I had to find a back way home because I could no longer drive on any of the main roads since it was obvious that I was going to get hit from behind! *Tr

Filed Incident Power trainNHTSA 10476916
SteeringTransmission & drivetrainElectrical system

Daughter/co-owner was driving car. Shifting from 1st in to 2nd gear. Loud clunk or rattle/clicking from unside. Car lost power steering, battery light came on. Could not control vehicle. Had to call tow truck. *Tr

Filed Incident Steering · Power train · Electrical systemNHTSA 10472498
Transmission & drivetrain

The transmission has failed at 66k miles - as I am researching this problem, I can see that many people have had premature transmission failures with their mini cooper and bmw has not been willing to address the problem. The cost to us will be approximately $10,000 to repair. *Tr

Filed Incident Power trainNHTSA 10470566

Mini Cooper transmission complaints by year

Cooper transmission problems, every year

Had a transmission problem with your 2005 Cooper? Tell other owners.

Your experience goes live straight away and helps every owner and buyer who checks this vehicle. Anonymous, free, no account.

Overall, how would you rate it? *

0/4000 · Please leave out names, phone numbers and your full VIN.

By posting you confirm it's your own, honest experience and agree to the rules. Safety defect? Also report it to NHTSA - that's how recalls start.

Source: U.S. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) complaints and recalls, checked . Complaints are owners' own reports and are not verified. How we use the data

Owners helping owners

Know before you drive.

Every experience you share - good or bad - shows on that vehicle's page and helps the next owner and buyer. Two minutes, anonymous.

Share your experience