Check a vehicle VIN check Latest recalls Latest complaints Common problems Rankings Compare vehicles Recall roundups All makes Guides Share your experience
Theme

Engine & cooling

2011 Subaru Forester Engine problems

Owners have filed 67 complaints about the 2011 Subaru Forester's engine & cooling with NHTSA - 46% of all its complaints, most recently on January 8, 2025. They describe 6 crashes, 4 fires and 2 injuries. Stalling, loss of power, oil consumption, overheating, head gaskets, timing chains and engine failure.

Complaints
67
Recalls
0
Crashes
6
Fires
4
Injuries
2
Deaths
0

Engine complaints

Engine & cooling

Oil consumption - subaru dealership confirmed there was an oil consumption problem over 1 qt per 1200 miles. Subaru of america would not repair under warranty or offer assistance as vehicle was just over extended warranty. 113K miles at time and the extended warranty was 8 years or 100k miles

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 11171433
Engine & cooling

On christmas eve, while driving on the garden state parkway in nj, car engine started making loud tapping noises. As I tried to pull off the road, engine noise became louder and when I finally was off the road , the noise turned to banging. No warning lights.Before I could turn off the engine, it stopped on it's own. From start of noise to stop was about 15 seconds. There was oil on bottom of vehicle and none in the engine. I check the oil frequently and have the car dealer serviced faithfully every 6000 miles,...

Read the full complaint

which is even less than subaru recommended intervals.. I had the car towed to that dealer. They told me the engine was a total loss and it would cost $9000 to repair. The car had 117000 miles on it.

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 11170102
Engine & cooling

Failed consumption oil test. Engine had to be replaced .I was told by subaru that their was no recall .My second subaru forester 2013 had same problem and its engine had to be replaced.

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 11142152
Engine & cooling

Tl* the contact owns a 2011 subaru forester. While driving approximately 50 mph, the vehicle stalled without warning. The contact coasted the vehicle to the side of the road with the help of a police officer. Subaru of gwinnett (2920 satellite blvd, duluth, georgia 30096) was made aware of the failure and diagnosed that there was a hole in the engine. The vehicle was not repaired. The vehicle was taken to an independent mechanic where it was also assessed. The failure mileage and vin were not available.

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 11113962
Engine & cooling

Engine burned out on interstate highway, metal filings in case, no warning lights came on the dash at any time. Come to find out there is no low oil light in this vehicle! Plus, there is a class action lawsuit against this year/make/model for excess engine oil use. Serviced this car at all recommended intervals and never let oil changes go beyond the recommended mileage. Have been very faithful with caring for this vehicle. The oil change was not due for another 1,000 miles when this occurred. Subaru dealership...

Read the full complaint

nearest to where the engine failed was unhelpful as was the national subaru company. Very disappointed in subaru's customer service as a whole. Did not receive communication regarding this problem and no warning from service managers at any time during servicing the vehicle.

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 11111629
Engine & cooling

Tl* the contact owns a 2011 subaru forester. The contact stated that the vehicle consumed an excessive amount of oil. There were no warning indicators illuminated. The vehicle was taken to an independent mechanic, but was not diagnosed or repaired. The vehicle was not taken to a dealer. The manufacturer was not notified of the failure. The approximate failure mileage was 131,879.

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 11099532
Engine & cooling

I have a 2011 subaru forester 2.5 Premium that had been consuming an exorbitant amount of oil ever since I got it. It requires that I add up to 1.2 Qts every 2 months to stay above the empty line on the dip stick. My brother told me recently he heard that there was a recall on some subaru vehicles during my year due to oil consumption issues. Therefore, I checked my vin both on this website and dubaru's website, but it didn't return anything regarding the oil consumption. Can I get some help with this issue as my warranty had already expired and this issue may be getting worse.

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 11093814
Engine & cooling

Our subaru forester began ticking, like a lifter was sticking, and the oil level of the synthetic oil was perfect. Then the car began to have a burning smell from the engine compartment. We took the car to our dealer huebueger, colo. Springs, colorado. The tech informed us that the car had technical service bulletins about these issues. The tech also said that a tsb is issued by an auto maker when there is a growing trend with an unanticipated problem, but does not warrant a recall. He said the irregular...

Read the full complaint

stamping of camshaft position sensor plates caused the eventual ticking and leaking from the camshaft carrier on both sides of the engine and this is what happened to our vehicle now warranting a $4,500 repair. Since the issue has been identified as a factory defect I called subaru support expecting financial help to rid the car of the defect. The woman was very obtuse and pretended not to understand the issue of responsibility of subaru. I don't understand the reason for technical service bulletins being released only to dealerships and mechanics. Isn't it logical and reasonable to alert the owners of vehicles that may develop oil leaks that could lead to a vehicle fire ? Isn't subaru admitting responsibility by issuing a tsb for a growing trend with an unanticipated problem. It seems irresponsible for the nhtsa and subaru not to notify owners of identified problems that could lead to serious safety issues. Please respond as soon as possible, I am 69 years old and this issue and the financial strain is very important. The applicable communication #"s of the tsb is 02-131-12r of oct. 2, 2012, 060000 Engine (pws). Sb-11-100 hr, november 27, 2012, irregular stamping of camshaft position sensor plate. The burning smell became overpowering on the way to the dealership. The tech advises that an oil leak is coming from the cam carriers on both sides defects

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 11089894
Engine & cooling

There is an oil leak in the head gasket and camshaft seal. This causes oil to drip and burn smoke. There is a fire risk to this. The cost of repairing this is extremely high. This seems to be a faulty part of all subaru foresters of this time period.

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 11082488
Electrical systemEngine & cooling

The vehicle stalls in traffic and at a stops, problem began in december 2017 and the battery was replaced immediately. In january 2018 it was taken to an authorized subaru dealer for repairs. The 60000 mile service was performed, it continued to stall and was returned to the dealer. The catalytic converters were replaced and it stalled in traffic when it was picked up from the dealership, it was returned. The wiring harness is now being replaced. Subaru field technicians and dealership technicians have tried to diagnose the issue.

Filed Incident Electrical system · Unknown or other · EngineNHTSA 11078852
Seats & seat beltsEngine & cooling

After 1 yr purchasing car new noticed high oil consumption. I was told normal wear by dealer. Now catalytic convertor is gone due to burning oil. Over $1500.00 To be replaced. I have to replace the rings so I won't have to replace the cat next year. I am going through 2 + qts. Of oil per 1000 miles .

Filed Incident Seat belts · EngineNHTSA 11073362
Engine & cooling

Tl* the contact owns a 2011 subaru forester. The contact stated that the tire pressure warning indicator illuminated. In addition, the contact noticed an abnormal knocking sound in the engine. During routine inspection, the technician informed the contact that the vehicle experienced excessive oil consumption. The technician added three quarts of oil to the engine. Mid-hudson subaru (1715 u.S. 9, Wappingers falls, ny) was contacted, but a diagnostic was not performed due to scheduling. The manufacturer was notified of the failure. The failure mileage was approximately 66,000.

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 11058010
Body, doors & structureDriver assistanceEngine & coolingCrash

When I parking my car into the parking place, the car suddenly gave a roar and rushed into someone's backyard. Although I pushed the brake pedal as deep as possible, the car rushed around 10 meters(?) And fully stopped after the car hit the rods of wood staircase(two of the rods of staircase was boken by my car). At that moment I just want shift the car from "d" to "r" (but not yet), the unintended acceleration happened to this car. Time: it happened between 2:30 to 3:00 pm on nov 30, 2017. Place: rushed...

Read the full complaint

into the backyards of 8352 kavanagh rd, dundalk md 21222, this backyards located on sandy plains road. Consequence: 1. Scratchs to front bumper. 2. Front bumper became loose after collision happened to the rod of staircase. 3. I have stiff muscles on both thighs for two days after this accident.

Filed Incident Structure · Electronic stability control (ESC) · EngineNHTSA 11052597
Engine & cooling

My 2011 subaru forester with 65,700 miles on it is sluggish into gear when first starting. I took it to the dealer who informed me it needed a new transmission ($5500+). I think this is outrageous. I read in forbes that there was an extension of the warranty (see https://www.Forbes.Com/sites/jensen/2017/07/07/facing-complaints-subaru-offers-extended-warranties-on-1-5-million-vehicles/#662fd3ac79dc) and wonder if this covers my vehicle?

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 11034637
Engine & cooling

I was driving on the highway in portland oregon and stopped at a light, as I began to accelerate going up a slight hill I noticed an awful smell like burning oil or tranny fluid. I picked up a family members to go to an appointment and they smelled it also. It went away as I continued but then next hill and the smell came back pretty strong. I found a subaru dealer/service dept. Near by and drove there. I was told that the front engine seal and cam carriers were leaking oil onto the exhaust. I asked if it was safe...

Read the full complaint

to drive and they said not too far because its leaking oil. Next day I took it to my normal subaru service dept. And they verified what the other service dept. Had told me with the exception of saying it was ok to drive it. They couldn't get me in for at least a week. My subaru forester only has 61,738 miles on it and I have never missed a maintenance service. I'm afraid now because the warranty expired a few months ago and I lost my job of 10 years just before turning 62. I bought this car because I thought subaru was a good long lasting car. I've looked and it appears that repairs could be as much as $2300. It also appears from my research that these engines have oil leak problems as well as other serious engine problems. I don't have the money for this repair. This shouldn't be happening. Why isn't there a class action law suit for these engines and all the money its costing all these folks because of failures. I am a quality rep for the aerospace industry and this just wouldn't be acceptable in any way, shape or form!

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 11021078
Engine & coolingFire

Tl* the contact owns a 2011 subaru forester. While driving approximately 55 mph, a ticking noise emerged from the engine compartment and the oil warning indicator illuminated. The vehicle started to slow down and then stopped. The contact coasted the vehicle to the shoulder of the road to a complete stop. The contact exited the vehicle, raised the hood, and observed smoke around the dipstick. The contact checked the oil and found that the reservoir was empty. The vehicle was towed to the dealer, but it was closed....

Read the full complaint

The manufacturer was notified of the failure. The manufacturer advised the contact of a technical service bulletin related to the oil consumption issue, but the vehicle had to be evaluated and then driven 1,200 miles in order for them to replace the engine block assembly. The vehicle was not repaired. The approximate failure mileage was 87,000.

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 10978799
Transmission & drivetrainEngine & cooling

My wife and I currently own a 2011 subaru forester we purchased new from hatfield subaru in columbus, ohio. We have always had it serviced at byers dublin subaru in columbus ohio. At the 25,000 mile mark both head gaskets were leaking so the mechanics at byers pulled the motor and replaced them. Just recently at the 33,000 mile mark I brought in my vehicle to byers for my 30,000 maintenance check also complaining of a strange noise. They informed me the head gasket was leaking again and the noise we heard was the...

Read the full complaint

transmission running low on fluid. They again pulled the motor and made repairs, however, when placing the motor back in the car a strange noise developed in the engine, they again pulled the motor adjusting the tensioning on the timing chain yet the noise was still present. They then contacted subaru technical support asking for assistance. They are currently pulling the motor for the fourth time with the intention on replacing the cylinder heads and cam shaft. Up until now I have been in contact with both dealerships expressing my concerns. I have also spoken with customer service, a supervisor, and a manager at subaru of america. The manager at subaru headquarters said they could only offer me 2500.00 Towards the purchase of a new vehicle the manager at hatfield where I purchased my vehicle from passed me off to a sales associate who only wanted to sell me a new subaru at full price to meet his end of the month february sales quota. The manager at byers where my car is being serviced has been less then forth coming as to the true status of my vehicle and I have not heard from him as to the status of my vehicle as promised in the last four business days. What concerns me the most is my wife and I now own a subaru with a long list of engine problems so early in its life and a transmission which has been ex

Filed Incident Power train · EngineNHTSA 10959866
Engine & cooling

Abnormal oil consumption which is of the oil consumption lawsuit. The oil warning lights did not turn but the car was already out of oil in 3 months of use (supposedly 6 month window for oil changes). The car started to become jerky but still managed to get home and had it checked. If there are no warning signs, it is possible it can die in the middle of a busy highway, which is extremely dangerous.

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 10957953
Engine & cooling

Tl* the contact owns a 2011 subaru forester. The contact stated that the engine emitted a strong burning odor and smoke while driving. The vehicle was taken to the dealer several times for the failure where it was diagnosed that the engine was leaking oil on the manifold. The dealer replaced the engine intake manifold, valve cover gasket, camshaft, sparks plugs, and engine cover seals; however, the failure was not corrected. The engine oil continued to leak. The manufacturer was notified. The failure mileage was 74,000.

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 10915727
Engine & cooling

Tl* the contact owns a 2011 subaru forester. The contact stated that the vehicle was burning oil at a higher rate than normal. The contact stated that the vehicle was burning a quarter of oil every thousand miles, which caused the oil consumption to surpass suggested amounts by the manufacturer. The dealer diagnosed that the vehicle was leaking oil from the pcv valve, causing the vehicle to burn oil. The vehicle was repaired; however, the failure recurred. The contact returned the vehicle to the dealer where it was...

Read the full complaint

diagnosed other leaks were the cause; however, the locations were not specified. The dealer placed a short block engine into the vehicle, but the failure recurred. The manufacturer was made aware of the failure who informed the contact of a pending lawsuit related to the failure. The failure mileage was 938.

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 10897609
Engine & cooling

My subaru is being tested for oil consumption use, I returned with 1 1/2 quart low after 948 miles. Tech stated it was on full after it was taken to garage. It was not checked in our presence. Car has no oil sensor and I fear the motor will lock up & I do not trust the subaru dealer now since they denied adding oil.

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 10809614
Engine & cooling

Vehicle has had abnormally high oil consumption since purchased. *Tr

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 10693405
Engine & cooling

Tl* the contact owns a 2011 subaru forester. The contact stated that the vehicle's oil consumption was excessive and that the engine oil would be depleted multiple times per week. The failure occurred multiple times. The vehicle was taken to the dealer where it was diagnosed that the oil consumption was normal. The vehicle was not repaired. The manufacturer was not made aware of the failure. The failure mileage was unknown.

Filed Incident Engine and engine coolingNHTSA 10681482
Engine & cooling

I purchased my 2011 subaru forester used from a dealership in ny. I started noticing that it was burning through oil. I took it to a subaru dealership and found out that it needs a new engine and that other people are having this problem as well. Subaru doesn't want to take responsibility for this issue though so I have to make a claim on my warranty and of course they have found a loop hole to not cover the repair (piston rings are damaged due to faulty cylinder walls and, conveniently, the cylinder walls are not...

Read the full complaint

considered an internal part so the warranty won't cover). Now I'm left with either replacing my engine or taking a large hit on my trade-in value. Had I known that I would've been replacing the engine less than 2 years after buying the car I would've negotiated a much lower price for the car or went with a different make/model. I cannot afford to replace an engine or buy a new car, I have no other choice than to continue to pour oil into this car and hope that I don't break down on the expressway or back roads during my 60 mile commute to and from work or when I have my child in the car. *Tr

Filed Incident EngineNHTSA 10672234
Engine & coolingBrakes

When the check engine light (cel) is activated by an emission control failure subaru has programmed a shut down of the anti-lock brake system (as well as shut down of cruise control). This abs shut down could occur for a simple loose gas cap which is common cause of cel failure. The section 3-16 on cel warning light/malfunction indicator does not inform the owner that a cel event will be accompanied by the disabling of the abs. The driver finds this out only because the cel is accompanied by blinking cruise light...

Read the full complaint

and steadily illuminated abs light. Per owner manual section 7-23 for 2011 forester when the abs is disabled the car/driver/passengers are a risk of loss of steering control and directional stability. Three cel events occurred from june 2013 to december 2014 for same problem because thermostat was not to be replaced per service bulletin 09-56-13/10/21/13 until ecm re-programming occurred. Therefore I was forced to drive without anti-lock brake system 3 times 6/13; 8/14 and 12/14 until repairs could be scheduled. I am requesting that subaru not be allowed to disable the abs for cel/emission control system problems. This is because I have had multiple unpredictable cel events some during weather conditions for which abs function was critical. The thermostat and gasket assembly wee replaced.

Filed Incident Engine and engine cooling · Service brakesNHTSA 10664131

Subaru Forester engine complaints by year

Forester engine problems, every year

Had a engine problem with your 2011 Forester? Tell other owners.

Your experience goes live straight away and helps every owner and buyer who checks this vehicle. Anonymous, free, no account.

Overall, how would you rate it? *

0/4000 · Please leave out names, phone numbers and your full VIN.

By posting you confirm it's your own, honest experience and agree to the rules. Safety defect? Also report it to NHTSA - that's how recalls start.

Source: U.S. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) complaints and recalls, checked . Complaints are owners' own reports and are not verified. How we use the data

Owners helping owners

Know before you drive.

Every experience you share - good or bad - shows on that vehicle's page and helps the next owner and buyer. Two minutes, anonymous.

Share your experience