Check a vehicle VIN check Latest recalls Latest complaints Common problems Rankings Compare vehicles Recall roundups All makes Guides Share your experience
Theme

Brakes

2021 Tesla Model S Brake problems

Owners have filed 16 complaints about the 2021 Tesla Model S's brakes with NHTSA - 9% of all its complaints, most recently on August 12, 2026. They describe 3 crashes, 0 fires and 0 injuries. Spongy or hard pedal, ABS faults, brake failure, noises, parking brake and brake fluid leaks.

Complaints
16
Recalls
0
Crashes
3
Fires
0
Injuries
0
Deaths
0

Brake complaints

Acceleration & cruise controlBrakes

The contact owns a 2021 Tesla Model S. The contact stated that while driving at various speeds with the cruise control feature engaged, the brakes independently activated without the brake pedal being depressed. No warning light was illuminated. The local dealer was contacted; however, the vehicle was not diagnosed or repaired. The manufacturer was made aware of the failure. The failure mileage was approximately 65,000.

Filed Incident Vehicle speed control · Service brakesNHTSA 11756406
Seats & seat beltsBrakesDriver assistance

I noticed it happened before but I couldn't quite figure out what happened! I was driving down the local road and got ready to go under a overpass and next thing u know my EV just slammed on brakes like I was about to hit someone! Seatbelt choked me and made me gag! But when I came through this time It caught me off but after that I realized there's a problem,especially going under that overpass! This couldn't been very dangerous to anyone! This is a VERY DANGEROUS and IMPORTANT SAFETY CONCERN! I STRIVE SAFETY AND THIS COULD BE FATAL!! I NEED TO REACH SONEONE IN SAFETY! ASAP

Filed Incident Seat belts · Service brakes · Forward collision avoidanceNHTSA 11737492
SteeringSuspensionBrakes

Front suspension has a popping and creaking sound when driving and turning steering wheel. Safety issue as sounds something is loose but Tesla says no issue it's the body flexing which is even scarier to hear the panels rattling if this is in fact true. Tesla will not do anything about it. Additionally the brakes and rotors squeal when pressed at slow speeds coming to full hard stop. Both front and back. Both brakes and rotors have 90% life and according to Tesla shouldn't need replacing until 90k miles due to...

Read the full complaint

the regen braking. The braking system does not engage as it should or how it is designed and car has 40k miles. Tesla uses the excuse that that they don't cover this as it's a wear and tear component. Which another issue because they don't know the reason of why it's doing this. They want customers to pay and replace the brakes and rotors. Many owners with same car experience this issue and is a design defect that can pose safety issues

Filed Incident Steering · Suspension · Service brakesNHTSA 11615154
Brakes

To avoid collision on the highway with a deer crossing in front of me, I braked very hard. The left rear brake caliper mount broke as a result. I did not lose brake fluid pressure, thankfully but this could've been a catastrophic failure. I contacted Tesla who seemed indifferent and blaming the incident on my driving and the mileage of the car ( 48,000 ). I have never in my life heard of a caliper mount breaking on any car with any number of miles. I'm sure it happens, but it should not happen on a car with 1000 hp.

Filed Incident Service brakesNHTSA 11605322
BrakesDriver assistance

Third time this week I have been thrown forward into the steering wheel with no cars or objects surrounding me.

Filed Incident Service brakes · Forward collision avoidanceNHTSA 11526251
BrakesDriver assistance

Another automatic phantom braking throwing us toward in the car with no objects or other cars in proximity.

Filed Incident Service brakes · Forward collision avoidanceNHTSA 11521948
Acceleration & cruise controlBrakes

On March 19, 2023, I put my Tesla in drive and it went into reverse . When I tried to brake the speed accelerated. We were unable to stop the vehicle, while driving in reverse the car hit two mailboxes and two ceramic flower pots. It has been over 6 weeks and Tesla will not return my calls or messages. My insurance company looked at the body of the vehicle for a repair estimate. Nothing indicated that there was a problem prior to the incident.

Filed Incident Vehicle speed control · Unknown or other · Service brakesNHTSA 11519299
Brakes

Im having total braking loss around freezing temps The issue occurs around freezing temps, after a car wash or if the roads are wet after driving on the highway for 20-30min without using the brakes. (Using one pedal driving) Last year I had the same issue and Tesla's position was something to do with detergent in the car washes I use. Now they're saying it's because I put the "wrong" size rear tires on the car. They were sold to me and installed by Tesla as the factory recommended winter tires and rim package....

Read the full complaint

They're saying that the abs sensor is detecting the error and automatically applying ABS brakes because of the mismatch tire size. However, the issue is not an intermittent braking loss, it's a complete braking loss. I'm also seeing abnormal front rotor wear. Tesla said this was an issue that was occurring on some other vehicles and they had a high level engineering team trying to figure it out. At the time mine was one of the first P2 refresh vehicles in Canada so I was guessing there weren't that many being used in below freezing temps since they weren't exporting to Europe at the time.

Filed Incident Service brakesNHTSA 11507071
BrakesDriver assistance

Our Tesla, in the "Full Self Drive" mode, has on more than one occasion applied the brakes suddenly without warning while traveling on the freeways. The date I indicate below was the last occurrence. I see that others have indicated this malady and I wanted to add our voice to this conversation. Thank you

Filed Incident Service brakes · Forward collision avoidanceNHTSA 11497620
BrakesDriver assistanceCrash

In August 2022 I was driving my Tesla S. I was traveling 25 miles an hour or less. I unfortunately lost consciousness for a very short time. My tesla then crashed into a parked car. There was snow emergency braking nor any emergency alarms. In theory describes shouldn't of happened with an emergency braking system.

Filed Incident Service brakes · Forward collision avoidanceNHTSA 11492305
BrakesCrash

Brakes are not strong enough to brake tires loose or cause anti lock. My Chevrolet Colorado out stops my Tesla. Hit an animal that my truck would not have. Helpless feeling.

Filed Incident Service brakesNHTSA 11471255
BrakesDriver assistance

The vehicle put the brakes on when on adaptive cruise, but with very few cars around. The last time, there was no car in front of me, but the vehicle braked so fast the the car behind me almost rear ended me. I've noticed that it happened twice on a South bound stretch of I-35 in Temple texas. This needs to be addressed or there is a strong potential for an accident.

Filed Incident Service brakes · Forward collision avoidanceNHTSA 11467559
BrakesCrash

It is still unknown, but I believe the brakes failed. My wife was driving and making a left turn into a residential neighborhood when she applied the brake and it didn't respond, even when pushing the pedal to the floor. All that resulted was a clicking noise. The brakes failing to respond, and the emergency braking not engaging did cause an impact with a curb and sidewalk. At the same time, the seatbelt did not lock on impact or when pushing the brake pedal to the floor. The safety of the my wife was put at risk...

Read the full complaint

as she could not stop the car. With the cars weight and the amount of power that it has, it creates a dangerous situation for anyone around, especially in a residential area. The vehicle is available for inspection and is currently at the Tesla Service Center. There was a warning light that said something regarding the "Hold" not working and another for "Regenerative Braking." I do have the four angle dash cam videos from the Tesla of both times that it did occur.

Filed Incident Service brakes · Unknown or otherNHTSA 11457411
BrakesDriver assistance

While in autopilot, the car brakes for no reason, phantom breaking. This happens while in right lane near exits, and happens inconsistently while in other lanes. It dropped from 83 on autopilot to 49 in one instance. The person in the back seat almost drove her head into the back of driver seat. The passengers will never buy a Tesla. Another issue, important controls for the car are not intuitive for use and provide distractions from driving. The blinkers and horn as well as tire pressure gauges and other items...

Read the full complaint

necessary for safety are too "non conforming". Someone please address these issues with Tesla. Also, almost every control is so small and flat with no raised markings, those with essential tremors are susceptible to not be able to reach or activate controls due to the extremely small size of the controls.

Filed Incident Service brakes · Forward collision avoidanceNHTSA 11452894
BrakesDriver assistance

Automatic emergency braking on interstate where it is dangerous to slam on the brakes in the middle of traffic.

Filed Incident Unknown or other · Service brakes · Forward collision avoidanceNHTSA 11452601
Acceleration & cruise controlBrakesDriver assistance

Driving on highway at 65-70 mph with auto pilot and speed control engaged. Went to change lanes from left to right. Put on turn signal, cancelled auto pilot by turning steering wheel to right and moved to open right lane. There were no vehicles around us at all. The car suddenly, unexpectedly, and very shockingly slammed on the brakes causing items to be tossed around in the car, engaging all of our seat belts with some discomfort, and sending some loud alarm or warning sound to go off in the car. It scared me, my...

Read the full complaint

wife and daughter very much. If there had been a vehicle in the land behind us, there's no way they could have avoided hitting us very violently and causing injury and property damage. This happened 2 or 3 times in my former 2016 model s, but I never expected it in this 2021 model. A google search will reveal the vast number of tesla drivers who have had the same or similar experiences.

Filed Incident Vehicle speed control · Service brakes · Forward collision avoidanceNHTSA 11373709

Tesla Model S brake complaints by year

Model S brake problems, every year

Had a brake problem with your 2021 Model S? Tell other owners.

Your experience goes live straight away and helps every owner and buyer who checks this vehicle. Anonymous, free, no account.

Overall, how would you rate it? *

0/4000 · Please leave out names, phone numbers and your full VIN.

By posting you confirm it's your own, honest experience and agree to the rules. Safety defect? Also report it to NHTSA - that's how recalls start.

Source: U.S. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) complaints and recalls, checked . Complaints are owners' own reports and are not verified. How we use the data

Owners helping owners

Know before you drive.

Every experience you share - good or bad - shows on that vehicle's page and helps the next owner and buyer. Two minutes, anonymous.

Share your experience