Check a vehicle VIN check Latest recalls Latest complaints Common problems Rankings Compare vehicles Recall roundups All makes Guides Share your experience
Theme

Brakes

Smart ED Brake problems by year

9 complaints filed with NHTSA about the Smart ED's brakes. Spongy or hard pedal, ABS faults, brake failure, noises, parking brake and brake fluid leaks.

Brake complaints by model year

YearBrake complaintsCrashesInjuriesRecalls
20165210
20151000
20142100
20131000

Latest ED brake complaints

2014 Smart EDBrakesCrash

Loss of most of the braking effectiveness, resulting in a collision. This vehicle had a Virginia State inspection performed the previous month and no brake failure dash lights were noted before the collision.

Filed Incident Service brakesNHTSA 11684251
2014 Smart EDBrakes

The brake booster malfunctioned while I was driving

Filed Incident Service brakesNHTSA 11497260
2016 Smart EDBrakesVisibility & wipers

Three weeks after got the car from carmax check engine light went on and the after a smell of burning oil every time after driving somewhere. Cruise control failure about a month and half after getting the car, spring shocks in bad condition. Front windshield replaced looks like by the writing on the upper corner driver side (pieces of glass found on the car). Cargo cover missing and no mats.

Filed Incident Unknown or other · Service brakes · Visibility / wiperNHTSA 11448747
2016 Smart EDBrakesCrash1 injury

Tl* the contact owned a 2016 smart fortwo. The contact stated that while driving at 25 mph and uncertain if whether he depressed the accelerator pedal or the brake pedal; the vehicle accelerated off the road and hit a tree. The air bags deployed upon impact. The contact sustained minor bruising at a result of the accident but did not seek medical treatment. A police report was not filed. The vehicle was totaled and remained at the scene of accident. The dealer nor the manufacturer nor the dealer had yet to be notified of the failure. The vehicle had yet to be towed from the scene of the accident. The possible failure mileage was 50,000.

Filed Incident Service brakesNHTSA 11383048
2016 Smart EDWheels & tiresBrakesFuel systemCrashFire

The brakes are slipping bad. They have been slipping since I bought the vehicle in 2016. The gas tank is leaking and has leaked into the cab of the car. The gas tank has been replaced 3 times.

Filed Incident Wheels · Service brakes · Fuel / propulsion systemNHTSA 11353926
2016 Smart EDBrakes

At 65mph on a freeway traveling straight when I had to brake for traffic I experienced a complete brake system failure. The vehicle swerved severely to the left and right entering both lanes luckily their was nobody was in those lanes it would have been an accident. There was such a severe direction change I thought the vehicle was going to roll over. The vehicle was towed to westminster mercedes-benz denver co dealer where they reported to me that the brake sensor,master cylinder and brake booster have to be replaced. It was a very uncontrolled stop!!!

Filed Incident Service brakesNHTSA 11021653
2015 Smart EDBrakes

While driving, brakes failed, brake pedal became impossible to depress with no brake response, and a warning light indicating a brake fault came on. Fortunately, driver was on a slow moving city street and was able to pull over and stop using hand brake for an emergency stop. Other electrical related glitches in this car can be 'reset' by turning off car and restarting. Driver tried that, error cleared, driver proceeded carefully, turning onto a quiet residential street. Brakes worked for two blocks, but on 3rd...

Read the full complaint

block same thing occurred approaching a stop sign - brake pedal became un-usably stiff with no apparent brake response, indicator light came back on, brakes did not work, hand brake was again used to slow and stop vehicle. Two more attempts to reset, no change, used hand-brake while moving vehicle out of street and into a legal parking spot. Vehicle towed to dealer. Dealer indicates there is a service bulletin about this issue, fixes problem, but deflects all questions about whether this is a serious defect that should be part of a product-wide recall. Dealer notes on repair form are equally evasive, claiming that they were unable to recreate the problem but did find fault codes in the computer. I am deeply concerned that smart/mercedes is trying to hide a known brake failure defect that could easily result in a catastrophic and fatal crash - had the driver been on the freeway or a very fast moving busy street, this might not have ended with a simple hand-brake panic stop. This issue, a rubbing wire harness that then causes a short, is well known enough that they have an internal service bulletin about it - if it is that common, they need to recall all impacted vehicles and fix/replace/immobilize/reinsulate the defective wire harness where it rubs on the frame, and they need to do it before someone is gravely injured or dies due to a known defect.

Filed Incident Service brakesNHTSA 10983170
2016 Smart EDTransmission & drivetrainBrakesEngine & cooling

On steep uphills and when you have come to a stop because of a red light or a stop sign, the engine seems to be too weak to push the transmission forward and actually the car my roll back and brakes go in a lock mode which creates a big safety issue.

Filed Incident Power train · Service brakes · EngineNHTSA 10885818
2013 Smart EDBrakes

The "brake malf" light went on as I was driving down hill, coming home from work. I pulled to a side street. The break would work if you pressed really hard. I had the car towed to the smart dealership.The dealership informed me that water leaked from underneath the passenger seat and corroded the fuse box connected to the breaks. I asked how water could get there he said from a spill. I informed him that nothing has spilled on that side and asked if it could be from the rain or leaking windshield wiper fluid. He...

Read the full complaint

said the rain can't get in unless the car window or door is open and that the windshield wiper fluid is somewhere else. There was no spill on the passenger side so I am not sure how the fuse box got corroded. Even if there was a spill, how can a spill inside your own car cause the breaks to malfunction!?? They need to fix this design flaw!!!! Having your brakes not work is a deadly situation for any driver to be in.

Filed Incident Service brakesNHTSA 10824087

Source: U.S. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) complaints and recalls, checked daily. Complaints are owners' own reports and are not verified. How we use the data

Owners helping owners

Know before you drive.

Every experience you share - good or bad - shows on that vehicle's page and helps the next owner and buyer. Two minutes, anonymous.

Share your experience